Redevelopment worries Sugar House

SUGAR HOUSE — Sugar House fans on Tuesday begged the Salt Lake City Council to save their eclectic neighborhood from a development they worry will bring a dulling down of a vibrant community.

The council, meeting at Sugar House's Nibley Park Elementary School for its monthly neighborhood outreach meeting, heard from about a dozen people Tuesday evening — and received a thick stack of comment cards from scores more. Most wanted to talk about the intersection of 2100 South and Highland Drive.

The block to the southwest of that intersection, known as the Granite block, is home to several unique local businesses — the Free Speech Zone, Artopia, Blue Boutique, Orion's Music, Sugar House Coffee, Pib's Exchange and others — but many residents and business owners worry plans for a redevelopment of the area will do away with its funky feel.

In December 2005, the council approved a zoning change on the block to allow for buildings as tall as seven or eight stories. Landowners, including Craig Mecham Management and California-based Red Mountain Retail Group, say they have plans to upgrade the area, though details have not yet been announced.

In February, businesses on the block began receiving eviction notices.

Orion's Music owner Andrew Fletcher on Tuesday said the zoning change "steamrolled over the wishes of the neighborhood."

One woman, who lives farther west in Salt Lake City but said she regularly shops on the Granite block, asked, "Why do we need to rip down that nice little Haight-Ashbury-type of street to put up more office space and more retail space that is not going to be used?"

Landowners hoping to redevelop the Granite block have told the Deseret Morning News they have no intention to change the area's mood — in fact, they hope to enhance it — and that they need to give it a face-lift because some buildings are out of shape.

Eric Nelson of Red Mountain said his plans would see "90 to 95 percent" of the area's buildings renovated but remaining where they are.

The developers say the local businesses currently located there could be part of the new development, but many business owners say they doubt they'll be able to afford it.

Simonsen, who tried unsuccessfully to revisit the zoning change shortly after taking office a little more than a year ago, has said he doubts the redevelopment can be stopped. But that doesn't mean the city can't guide it in a way that would preserve its character.

On Tuesday, he asked the council to consider a handful of possible actions and received tentative support for his ideas.