Mitchell still mentally unfit

Published: Monday, Dec. 18 2006 2:18 p.m. MST

A man accused of kidnapping Elizabeth Smart in 2002 again was declared mentally unfit to stand trial Monday after screaming at a judge to "forsake those robes and kneel in the dust."

Brian David Mitchell was removed from the courtroom after a loud stream of outbursts. Third District Judge Judith Atherton also reviewed a doctor's report that said he is not participating in therapy.

"I find the defendant continues to be incompetent to stand trial," Atherton said.

Mitchell and his estranged wife, Wanda Barzee, 61, are charged with kidnapping Smart from her home in June 2002. She was 14 at the time.

The hearing was delayed for more than two hours so Mitchell could be transported from the Utah State Hospital in Provo, where he had refused to leave.

The judge, who had not seen him for a year, demanded that Mitchell appear. Once inside the courtroom, however, his appearance was brief.

"Repent ye, repent ye. Forsake your idolatry," said Mitchell, his wrists restrained with a chain around his belly.

"How dare you sit in those filthy robes, those robes of false priesthood. Forsake those robes and kneel in the dust," he told the judge.

Mitchell, 53, had made similar outbursts at previous hearings.

He and Barzee so far have been found unfit to face charges tied to Smart's nine-month odyssey, from Salt Lake City to California and back to Utah, where they were discovered walking a suburban street in 2003.

In Barzee's case, her attorneys are asking the Utah Supreme Court to overturn Atherton's order forcing her to take medication to restore competency.

Doctors have been trying to treat Mitchell without drugs. But after the scene in court, prosecutor Kent Morgan said a similar request to forcibly administer drugs likely would follow.

"He's not competent. It's because he's not participating in any therapy," Morgan said.

Mitchell's attorney, Vernice Trease, disagreed that her client was incompetent simply because he wasn't participating in therapy. As she made her argument, Mitchell could be heard ranting in the holding area next to the courtroom.

The judge set a hearing for Jan. 12 to start the process toward determining if Mitchell fits the U.S. Supreme Court requirements for forced medication.

"I believe his behavior is somewhat controllable," Morgan said after the hearing.

Mitchell and Barzee are charged with aggravated burglary, aggravated kidnapping and aggravated sexual assault. They also are accused of attempted aggravated kidnapping, a charge linked to one of Smart's cousins.

No one from the Smart family attended the hearing.

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS