From Deseret News archives:
Utah jury selection upheld
Judge rejects claim that Hispanics are underrepresented
In a 42-page ruling, 4th District Judge Lynn Davis denied a motion to stop jury trials for two of defense attorney Mike Esplin's clients and potentially all defendants with pending court cases because of Esplin's concern with the jury-selection system.
Davis' ruling said Esplin did not present enough convincing evidence that Hispanics were being systematically excluded from jury pools. However, he did acknowledge the potential impacts of the jury-pool racial inequity concern, which, if proven to be true, could bring the judicial system to a screeching halt.
"The court notes that the defendants' generic attack/criticism of the Master Jury List is a broad, global attack on the jury selection system for the entire state of Utah," Davis wrote in his ruling. "The statewide implications on the criminal justice system are enormous."
Esplin argued that racially imbalanced juries are constitutional violations of his clients' rights the right to a jury of their peers.
Davis ruled Esplin failed to present enough evidence for the second and third factors.
Citing case law, Davis ruled that "defendants overestimated the number of Hispanics that are legally available for jury service."
Due to potential issues of "citizenship status and language barriers," as well as the requirement to be a naturalized citizen, Davis wrote, the number of Hispanics in Utah County does not instantly translate into the number of potential jurors.
Although Esplin's two clients are not Hispanic, they gave him permission to file the motions on their cases and agreed to the inevitable delays.
The clients, Daryl Otterson and Jacob Loveless, are awaiting trial on felony cases of sex abuse and aggravated assault charges, respectively.
Esplin said he plans to appeal Davis' ruling because he wants to see more focus dedicated to gathering demographic information about potential jury members.
"(My clients) are being denied due process (rights) because there's no way to obtain the information," he said.
The Master Jury List kept by the Utah's Administrative Office of the Courts is used to summon individuals for jury trials.
Comments
- Who is Oprah's heir apparent? 11:39 a.m.
- Florida No. 1, TCU 4 in AP Top 25 11:34 a.m.
- Fed under fire, public anger mounts 11:28 a.m.
- No quagga mussels at Bear Lake 11:27 a.m.
- Former health chief: Ignore guideline 11:11 a.m.
- Sen. moderates frustrate other Dems 10:57 a.m.
- Yellowstone grizzly deaths down 10:52 a.m.
- Atheist groups flourish on campuses 10:37 a.m.
- Griffin edges Ortiz in split decision 10:26 a.m.
- China mine disaster recounted 10:02 a.m.
- Glenn Beck to enter politics?
- BYU records with win
- Police link alcohol to murder
- Jazz outlast Pistons in overtime
- Utah Utes whip SDSU
- Cougars turn focus to dreaded rivals
- Former BYU professor remembered
- Y. coach Hill up for Portland State job
- Cougars put the fun back in football
- Kirilenko heating up for the Jazz
- Buttars wants to limit gay rights laws
194 - Palin plans tour stop in Utah
173 - Glenn Beck to enter politics?
165 - Palin's book shows she's unqualified
122 - BYU records with win
115 - Officer cleared in Cardall Taser case
103 - BYU cuts Women's Research Inst.
100 - Jazz finally win in San Antonio
98 - Utes knock off rival Aggies
93 - Huntsman pleased with Obama
87
A little after midnight Wednesday morning, about 21 hours ago as I write...
There's a lot of reason to leave your plastic home as you shop:
Um, championship or no, the stadium is still a big mistake. The finances...
. . . is what we had prior to January 20, 2009. NOW we've escaped that....
Home field left when ByU got 2 beat downs this year. ByU barely beat SDSU and...
I am sorry that you missed the sarcastic undertone in the message. Of course...
Beck represents one side of the ongoing Republican civil war; people like Jon...
JimP-you aren't so old. I remember when Hitler attacked Poland. I was 9 yrs...
I would have thought we would have had more Temples in Phillipines since...
I have known Michelle for 40 years. I went to high school with her for the...
"No one-not even one who has not heard of the Bible or of Christ has an...
The yewts are great at RUNNING UP THE SCORE! Look what they did to Wyo....


You can be the first to comment on this story.