From Deseret News archives:

Utes should get rid of nickname

Published: Sunday, Sept. 24, 2006 12:40 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Maybe it's time.

Maybe this should all be cleared up before the divorce lawyers get involved.

Maybe the Utes shouldn't be the Utes anymore.

I'm not talking about the Utes, of course. Anyone with membership in the Ute Indian Tribe should be Utes forever and ever, amen.

It's the University of Utah Utes whose time, like the buffalo, has probably passed.

For several decades now, the propriety of universities using Native American nicknames and mascots has been debated.

Some universities — like Stanford, which changed from Indians to Cardinal, or St. John's, which went from Redmen to Red Storm — washed their hands of the whole thing long ago. Others, like Utah, have slowly but surely disassociated themselves from Indian imagery while still hanging onto the nickname.

A year ago, the University of Utah dodged a death knell when it appealed an NCAA ruling that it needed to drop its nickname or face postseason athletic sanctions.

Story continues below
An endorsement from the Ute Tribe expressing favor with the "respectful relationship" between the school and tribe allowed the Utes to see another season of sunrises.

But now, not more than a year later, some tribe members are disgruntled. As reported by Dennis Romboy and Lucinda Dillon Kinkead of the Deseret Morning News, various Ute officials are upset that special "Ute" scholarships promised by the U. have not materialized.

The U. has responded by saying there was never a quid pro quo — scholarships for nickname — and never will be.

However, school officials have admitted to discussions about "support" for Ute Tribe education.

I don't know who's right, but even the revelation that such talks have taken place is demeaning to both parties.

It translates "respectful relationship" between the school and tribe to mean "bigger, better deal" for the Utes.

The Ute Indian Tribe should get all the higher educational opportunities it qualifies for and deserves but no more than the Shoshone, the Paiute, the Goshute and the Navajo.

Or the palefaces.

Just as when use of a nickname becomes offensive, it's time to lose the nickname; when use of a nickname comes with strings attached, it's also time to lose the nickname.

The University of Utah has had a long and dignified history being Utes. But times change and so can nicknames. The last thing the school, or the state, needs is another scandal over scholarships.


Lee Benson's column runs Sunday, Monday, Wednesday and Friday. Please send e-mail to benson@desnews.com and faxes to 801-237-2527.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Editorial: Poor welcome for Palin

Hard to believe there are those poor deluded souls that want Palin as the...

Letters: Climate debate over

Why do differences of opinion always have to be blamed on Al Gore or Rush...

Editorial: Poor welcome for Palin

Daniel is right I think the opinion page in a news paper is not any place for...

Loyal to Cougarettes, Crimson Line

I don't know about the first comment. My first reaction to the photo was...

...and who is Southern Jaguars??

Thanksgiving food for thought

I would like raise my cup and tell all of my gay brothers and sisters in the...

Charm vs. content. Special interests vs. the public good. Reality vs. fuzzy...

The biggest evil and disaster of giving these illegal enemy combatants...

Letters: Climate debate over

It's not MY fault the polar icecaps are melting. It must be the LIBERALS...

I read these posts all the time. I can't take it anymore. It's not a...

Advertisements