From Deseret News archives:

No, Fantasia is not an actress

TV movie about 'Idol' winner is laughably bad

Published: Friday, Aug. 18, 2006 9:27 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
PASADENA, Calif. — I'm going to try to put this as nicely as I possibly can.

The "American Idol" winner plays herself in a new made-for-TV movie about her life ... and she's not convincing in the role.

The woman can't act. Apparently, she can't even behave naturally on camera, because she's not even being asked to act. She's just behaving by playing herself.

Unconvincingly.

It is by no means all Barrino's fault that "The Fantasia Barrino Story: Life Is Not a Fairy Tale" is, well, bad. If she were the most talented actress in Hollywood, she couldn't make this melodramatic, overwrought, clumsy movie into something good.

As a matter of fact, Barrino is smarter than the people who made the movie. She resisted the idea of playing herself when Lifetime bought the rights to her autobiography.

"I was like, 'Well, who is going to play me, and what is she going to look like? I want to meet her,'" Barrino said. "But when they came to me, they said, 'Well, they want you to play yourself.'

"I'm like, 'No. I don't act. I sing.' They said, 'Well, they feel like if you play yourself, it will come across."'

Story continues below
Just a bit of unsolicited advice for Barrino — in the future, go with your first instinct.

Barrino's story became familiar to all those tens of millions of "American Idol" fans during that show's third season. She was a 19-year-old unwed mother who couldn't read and had survived rape. There was some controversy over her being an "Idol" contestant, let alone the winner, because her story was indeed hardly the stuff of fairy tales.

"When you hear the word 'Idol,' people think that you have to be a certain way," Barrino said. "You have to be a perfect person. Your slate has to be clean. You have to be a role model in people's eyes. And when I went, I was the only one that had dropped out of school, that I had a child at a young age. I wasn't the perfect person that they thought that the idol should be."

It has all the makings of a compelling TV movie ... but it didn't turn out that way. Right from the start, when two identified people ask her if she wants to quit "American Idol" because the show has gotten some nasty e-mail about her, it's just badly written (in addition to the bad acting). And director Debbie Allen takes such a heavy-handed approach that reality seems utterly unbelievable.

And, more disappointing, it's uninvolving.

"The whole journey is what touched me, because Fantasia's story is a story that belongs to all of us — all of us who have been challenged," Allen said. "All of us who have been told, 'No, you can't,' but we ultimately find out, 'Yes, you can."'

What a beautiful thought that, somehow, resulted in an often laughably bad television movie.

And a little more unsolicited advice, this time for Lifetime and the movie's producers. The next time you look for someone to carry a telefilm, hire someone who can actually act.


E-mail: pierce@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Fox

Fantasia Barrino of "American Idol" stars in movie about her life.

previousnext

Latest comments

I hope Donny wins. His humility, courage and humor are very refreshing....

Boys basketball rankings

but it is Provo's Craig Drury polishing his 8 rings as head coach.

Expect epic clash on the line

Like the newspaper said, "...the first time since '84 national...

I think Mya did not deserve the nine's from the 3 judges on her free dance -...

College football will NEVER revert to the old bowl system. It has gone too...

We don't need another layer of government, which obviously represents more...

Utah GOP opposes ethics initiative

And this surprises someone? It's too easy in Utah to deceive the masses....

We cannot afford this monstrosity! Any claims that it will save money are...

I grew up in SLC and have always been a huge BYU fan. Honestly I can say most...

These are not essential government programs needed to ensure our national...

Advertisements