From Deseret News archives:

Senate OKs immigration bill

Bennett yea, Hatch nay; tough talks lie ahead

Published: Friday, May 26, 2006 9:27 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — Legislation to secure U.S. borders and offer millions of illegal immigrants access to the American dream cleared the Senate on Thursday, a rare election-year reach across party lines and a triumph for President Bush.

The 62-36 vote cleared the way for arduous summertime compromise talks with the House and its get-tough measure — with no guarantee of success.

Utah's two Republican senators diverged in their votes. Sen. Bob Bennett voted for the bill, saying "it's not perfect, but it's a necessary step." Sen. Orrin Hatch voted against it, saying "it grants the largest amnesty ever undertaken in any country, at any time."

The Senate bill has little in common with the House bill with which it must be reconciled.

Both bills include money to better secure the borders. However, the Senate bill provides a new guest worker program and gives an eventual shot at citizenship to many of the estimated 11 million to 12 million illegal immigrants. The House bill, focused on enforcement, includes no such provisions. It does, however, make it a felony to be in the U.S. illegally.

Hatch is expected to be part of the team that will negotiate the compromise between the two bills. "I'll work to find a way to secure our borders in a way the American people can accept," he said.

Story continues below
Following the Senate vote, Bennett said the bill is a move in the direction of comprehensive immigration reform, because it would strengthen the borders and include "practical solutions" such as a guest-worker program.

"We must enable the border patrol agents to focus on apprehending criminals, drug runners and terrorists, instead of being overwhelmed by those seeking legitimate employment," he said in a statement.

Hatch disagreed. "I can't support this — it creates more problems than it fixes," he said in a statement. "We passed some strong border security provisions, and that's good. But blanket amnesty doesn't work, regardless of how it's disguised."

U.S. Rep. Chris Cannon, R-Utah, who hopes to be part of the negotiation team, was optimistic Thursday that a compromise with the Senate could be reached before an August break.

"I have high hopes we'll be able to solve this problem and get a final bill to the president for his signature in the next couple months," Cannon said. "That will take a concerted effort. I think even the Senate has figured out the American people really want a solution."

Those watching the debate in Utah acknowledged the immigration debate is far from over.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image

Sen. Bob Bennett

previousnext

Latest comments

Do you want them to look the other way when they come across a law being broken?

Letters: Modest tax hike needed

Mr Vincent, If you belive in your heart that you don't pay enough taxes......

Builder changing Payson plans

Why shouldn't he get approval if the project is a good one? Should he be...

Pitta doesn't win award

To: Re: Lame | 7:34 p.m. Dec. 10, 2009 He is a senior. I don't even know...

Letters: Reid sold his memory

Isn't this the guy who got up and gave a speach declaring the war is...

I agree with Lowell and laugh at both of us, but I love The Muppet Christmas...

With the collective bargaining agreement possibly changing in the NFL, rumor...

Austria passes gay civil unions bill

In 2006, the parliament of France courageously rejected same-gender marriage...

Texas preps strike Nike deal

I'm sorry but you must have never seen sports outside of Utah. Texas 1500...

Pitta doesn't win award

Why would a junior with worse numbers get the award if the senior out did him...

Advertisements