From Deseret News archives:

Lawmakers hold poor hostage

Published: Thursday, May 25, 2006 11:48 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
If excuses were dollars, the Utah Legislature could easily have appropriated $2 million for emergency medical services for blind and disabled Utahns.

But in a special session Wednesday, lawmakers didn't even debate the issue of poor people's dental care. They did approve spending $15 million to build a 270-car parking garage east of the Utah Capitol.

Some lawmakers said they couldn't single out funding dental services when so many other Medicaid issues deserve just as much or more consideration. But as an "optional" service, dental care deserved to be singled out because of great demand, the relative low cost and the tremendous public health benefit. After all, lawmakers singled out Medicaid dental and vision care three years ago, when the funding was intially axed.

Others resented Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr., for placing the matter before the lawmakers in special session. Refusing to fund emergency dental services could potentially make lawmakers appear insensitive to the needs of the poor and disabled. But politically, they didn't want to acquiesce to Huntsman, who isn't facing election in the fall and has plenty of political capital to expend.

Story continues below
Some lawmakers said emergency dental services could be funded by the Utah Department of Health now, but that's problematic, too. The Huntsman administration argues that such a move would require legislative approval. Even if it was technically possible, would it be prudent of health department officials to fund a service lawmakers specifically refused to consider in special session?

It's important not to paint with a broad brush here. The Legislature — on a party line vote — refused to consider this matter. Several Democrats expressed outrage that in a time of plenty the dental needs of Utah's poorest residents were not addressed.

Credit is due Huntsman, who clearly understands that people who would qualify for this assistance have little or no resources to seek dental care on their own. Their needs are urgent.

Through political maneuvering on the part of Republicans, lawmakers didn't have to stand up and be counted on this $2 million appropriation. But their political challengers can still call into question why, at a time when the state has sufficient resources to address this need, that they didn't stand up on behalf of people who most need their help.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

35% of the Utah population is about 960,000 people. Looks like that's more...

Letters: Growing jobless rate

Why the growing jobeless rate?, because they say the dollar is now worthless....

Letters: Moral code lacking

"Premarital abstinence helps keep our children healthy both physically and...

House passes health care bill

Too expensive! We cannot afford this. It will permanently stifle the...

Letters: DUI standards differ?

Ever been on the freeway between 6:30-7:00 am and seen the Salt Lake City...

As a Latter-Day Saint I am please that the Gay community wants...

Go RSL! Put out the Fire!

Letters: Liberal rant amusing

If you can't back up your claims with facts, you shouldn't make them. That...

I think what Matheson is trying to do is get both parties to agree on parts...

Seniors helped BYU regroup

The on-side kick comment was not about this years WYO-UTAH game (which was...

Advertisements
Advertisement