Why do many Christians go to fiction for religion?

Books such as 'Da Vinci Code' may fill a void for some

Published: Saturday, May 13 2006 12:00 a.m. MDT

Walk into any mega-chain bookstore these days and you're confronted by evidence of the Great Church Cover-up.

Front and center is the holy grail of conspiracy theories itself, "The Da Vinci Code." With 46 million copies in print — almost one for every six Americans — "Code" is still atop the best-seller lists and will bring the story to the big screen May 19 in the United States.

Then there are stacks of "Code" stepchildren, like "The Templar Legacy," "The Secret Supper" and "The Last Templar." You'll also find a fresh printing of 1982's "Holy Blood, Holy Grail," which first spun the modern image of Jesus Christ, family man.

Deeper in the store, near the Bibles, are a number of books rebutting "Code."

The public's unquenchable thirst for juicy alternatives to the "greatest story ever told" prompts the question: Why are so many people getting their church history from pulp fiction? The answer may be that even Christians — Roman Catholics, mainline Protestants and evangelicals — haven't learned it anywhere else.

"I think the book does fill a void; this is a story, and the churches have gotten away from storytelling," says David Turk, provost and vice president for academic affairs at the evangelical Alliance Theological Seminary in Nyack, N.Y. "People have a real need to know, not only did George Washington chop down the cherry tree, but what was Jesus' life like? We want to know, and the book raises questions that strike home. Churches can't run from it."

Dan Brown's book, a work of fiction that cleverly states it is based on real documents, offers theories that have riled much of the Christian world — that Christians saw Jesus as a mortal until a church council decided otherwise in the year 325, that the early church rejected "gospels" that humanized Jesus, and that Jesus married Mary Magdalene and had children with her.

Even though virtually all Christian scholars insist that Brown's plot is nothing more than fantasy, many also understand why the book has become a phenomenon. So few people have been given a grounding in church history, they say, that "Code" seems intriguing, even plausible.

"From a Catholic perspective, for the last 30 or 40 years, we've had a poor level of religious instruction," says Carl Olson, co-author of "The Da Vinci Hoax." "Good Catholic people in their 30s, 40s, 50s know nothing about church history. Where do they turn? And remember, Christianity stands or falls on its historical claims to a large degree. If Jesus wasn't who we say he was, it's all bunk."

Get The Deseret News Everywhere

Subscribe

Mobile

RSS