From Deseret News archives:

'Texas' travesty

Published: Sunday, April 30, 2006 6:32 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
PASADENA, Calif. — We've grown accustomed to "reality" shows featuring obnoxious people who can't get along, creating a program that's watchable only in the way that you can't turn your head if you happen upon a gruesome accident.

But on PBS?

"Texas Ranch House" isn't quite Fox's "Unan1mous," but it's too far down that road to avoid comparisons. It's eight hours (tonight-Thursday from 7-9 p.m. on Ch. 7) of people in a thoroughly unpleasant situation acting thoroughly unpleasant toward one another.

It's the latest in a series of "House" programs — "Frontier House," "Manor House," "Colonial House" — that attempt to put modern-day people into the lives of people in the past. In this case, it's a circa-1867 "Texas Ranch House." It's hot. It's dry. It's loaded with unpleasant swarms of flies and unpleasant confrontations.

Ranch foreman Stan Johnston fights with the cook, Ignacio "Nacho" Quiles. Nacho fights with ranch owner Bill Cooke. Bill fights with his wife, Lisa. The people trying to re-create a genuine 1867 experience fight with the people who refuse to play their roles as they ought to.

And everybody complains about everything all the time.

Story continues below
"You're a very small group of people stuck in the middle of nowhere. . . . And if you don't like each other, it's not a very good situation," said Maura Finkelstein, who was supposed to be a servant but insisted on being a cowboy.

(Certainly admirable in a 21st-century woman, but out of place for a 19th-century woman.)

How did she feel about being a maid — the historically accurate role for a woman in 1867?

"I was very angry. I actually thought that I might have the possibility of starting out as a cowboy and not necessarily the maid, so it was a disappointment at first," Finkelstein said.

"I never felt like it was 1867," she added, oblivious to the fact that she helped undercut the whole basis for "Texas Ranch House."

"There was a spectrum of the commitment to playing by the rules. . . . There were several people that were very, very committed to it and remained committed to it," Bill Cooke said. "Others weren't as much on board with that. And it kept things fractured, if you will."

Fractured and unpleasant. The eight hours seem endless.


E-mail: pierce@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Wyman Meinzer,Thirteen/Wnet New York

Johnny Ferguson, Jared Ficklin, Rob Wright and Ian Roberts ride out on "Texas Ranch House."

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

Alta shortstop makes Team USA

I enjoyed watching the duke brothers. it is quite sad that if Brock wasnt...

Thank you. Such a great reminder to all of us parents of the importance of...

Heck, I've had some major depression in the past, but I still am able to go...

Letters: Gays' parades offensive

1st Pagan | 4:09 p.m. Did you read my posting? I said I agree that the...

Reagan much-beloved in Utah

Reagan was a war criminal. His administration was responsible for countless...

Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're not all out to get you.

Yes I want a Supporters Sheild, and a "Western Conference Championship...

5A: Miners' Cantwell makes name

Yeah, those comments are ridiculous, Cantwell is a stud and definitely the...

The NIMBY attitude is getting so old.

Protests against Phoenix LDS temple

And why were there were so many troubles with neighbors when they proposed...

Advertisements