Somebody forgot to tell the guy whose computer-consulting firm does the national coaches' association women's gymnastics rankings about a change in procedure that was accepted last spring.
The result is that this week's rankings changed dramatically from Monday to Tuesday, and the University of Utah jumped from sixth to third on the team poll.
"A little bit of disorganization and lack of follow-through but it's a volunteer organization," is the way Ute coach Greg Marsden described the problem that was quickly corrected.
The coaches' association chose last spring, with just one "no" vote, to have the first seven weeks of the 2006 rankings go by season average, but no one told Steve Troester, who does the computerized rankings through inputs from the coaches and posts them on his Web site each Monday during the season.
As in years past, his rankings for the first two weeks of 2006 were posted this week by high score. Once informed about the change, Troester re-ranked everything by average, though some teams have had only one meet and others haven't yet competed.
In a Tuesday e-mail to member coaches, the National Association of Collegiate Gymnastics Coaches for Women president, Mike Lorenzen of Stanford, accepted responsibility.
The result is that Georgia, with a season average of 195.762, is now No. 1 with Michigan (195.675) second and Utah (195.25) third. When done by high score Monday, Alabama was first with 196.15, but its average (195.20) now has it fourth. Utah's high of 195.675 had it ranked sixth Monday. Utah State (190.40) is 32nd.
Teams with only one meet so far are ranked according to that single score. BYU is not ranked, as its one score (190.075) was apparently not officially reported. It would be 34th.
The Utes lost their No. 1 vault ranking and dropped to second behind Alabama. Utah's high vault was 49.325, best in the country for the first two weeks, but its average is 49.10 to Alabama's 49.125. Utah State is 25th, 48.325. Utah now ranks third on beam (48.662), fifth on floor (48.887) and 15th on bars (48.60).
Marsden said if he'd had a choice, he would just have left the rankings this week by high score once they were posted that way. "It just proves once again how meaningless the rankings are," he said with a chuckle.
Lorenzen said he thought it appropriate to make the correction immediately.
Nebraska's Emily Parsons (39.425 average) retained her No. 1 all-around ranking and visits Utah Friday at 7 p.m. with her now-sixth-ranked team that had been fourth.
Utah State's Jessica Parenti, seventh by high score, dropped out of the top 25. Utah's Nicolle Ford (39.20) moved up from eighth to sixth. USU's Katie Omann (38.975) is tied for 15th. Ford now ranks fourth on both bars and beam.As always, the rankings criteria will change in the eighth week, when most teams will have enough meets to have a Regional Qualifying Score, an average of six meets with at least half of the scores on the road.
Revised NCAA women's gymnastics poll
Jan. 16, by season average Rank Average High
Rank Average High
1 Georgia 195.762 195.825
2 Michigan 195.675 195.675
3 Utah 195.250 195.625
4 Alabama 195.200 196.150
5 Stanford 194.950 194.950
6 Nebraska 194.887 195.675
7 Penn State 194.875 194.875
8 Florida 194.737 195.900
9 Auburn 194.487 195.30010 Iowa State 194.075 194.100
- When it rains, it pours: Utes get washed away...
- BYU blanks hapless Savannah State, 64-0
- Despite the loss, Savannah State coach...
- High school football: Bingham accepts invite...
- Jimmer Fredette trying to keep his head up as...
- BYU's senior day emotional for Cougar coach...
- Dick Harmon: Regardless of circusmtances,...
- High school football: Timpview overcomes...
- BYU's Hill plans to return for senior... 116
- When it rains, it pours: Utes get... 114
- Runnin' Utes lose defensive battle at... 68
- Utes still have outside chance at... 37
- UHSAA's Board of Trustees assigns high... 36
- BYU blanks hapless Savannah State, 64-0 32
- For BYU, it's not about opponent... 30
- Freshman Jake Toolson leads Cougars... 21