From Deseret News archives:

Inquisition of poor Judge Alito seemed un-American

Published: Friday, Jan. 13, 2006 5:35 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Poor Samuel Alito. He did not tell the Democratic senators who grilled him what they wanted to hear. He did not say he would vote to overturn Roe v. Wade if he made it to the Supreme Court, and that it would not matter a bit what the specific case was about or what the arguments were. And he did not tell them something else. He did not say he was a bigot.

That's what the first two days of nationally televised hearings of President Bush's nominee were about. The Democrats had one issue in mind above all others — abortion — and they wanted Alito to say something extreme enough to justify their pre-ordained opposition to him.

If you do what Alito did, if you do not give the Democrats something on the order of a confession that, deep down, you don't think women have any rights, you know what to expect. Pretty soon you will have Sen. Ted Kennedy in your face, doing his superb imitation of one of the louts sitting on the House Committee on un-American Activities during its three-decade run beginning in the 1930s.

Those were the days when some congressmen were ruining lives by trying to show that their victims were once members of this or that group that just may have had an association with the Communist Party. They often exhibited a coarseness of manner equaled by a lack of brilliance. An illuminating moment came when a historically confused representative asked whether the Elizabethan playwright Christopher Marlowe was a commie, accounts of the committee tell us.

Story continues below
Kennedy's bugaboo was Alito's membership in Concerned Alumni of Princeton, a now-defunct group expressing worries in the early 1970s on such matters as the university's overturning of its all-male tradition, kicking ROTC off campus and admitting minorities with lower academic accomplishments than required of non-minorities. Apparently, at least some of its members wrote some stuff that you would not want to hoist high in a parade down the center of town, but members of a group that Kennedy belongs to have done the same — and worse. You don't have to go back so awfully far to find some Democrats making unbelievably racist remarks.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Thunder rolls by Jazz

Even sloan uses 0 cliques at halftime interview, instead, putting his...

Won't they be dimmer? Won't you have to buy more for the same intensity of...

Thunder rolls by Jazz

Todd, The players have obviously responded to our new and restructured front...

Korver's return hits snag

Korver you need to man up! There has been better players than you that have...

BYU 30 Seatlle U. 21 and third place.

Hall's legacy measured today

like it or not, you tend to remember people on things that stand out, 5 INTs,...

Way to go Seattle U.

Texas survives scare by A&M

Colt has the most wins as a starting qb in college football history. The...

Rivalry has had some 'turkeys'

Ok, what have you got against Santa Claus? That's just unAmerican.

Texas survives scare by A&M

One of the best rivalries in the country. Nice wake up call for UT. Next...

Advertisements