From Deseret News archives:

IHC kills competition, MDs say

They tell lawmakers about being in network's shadow

Published: Thursday, Nov. 3, 2005 10:36 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Other insurance companies have already had their chance. So have hospitals. And on Thursday, it was doctors' turn to talk to lawmakers about the difficulties of competing against the state's largest health-care network.

A panel of six physicians spent three hours discussing competition with a legislative task force assigned to investigate Intermountain Health Care's dominance in Utah's health-care market.

For five of the six doctors, the theme was largely the same: IHC has a good panel of physicians, is a strong insurance company and runs sound hospitals. But when you combine the three, as IHC has done, the effect is to squeeze out anyone not part of the IHC network.

"It's not that any one of the divisions is inherently bad . . . but together, all three of them with their little nuances and the small amounts of leverage they can provide each other makes for an unfair competitive layout," St. George cardiologist David Boorman told members of the Privately Owned Health Care Organization Task Force.

Craig Armstrong, a Logan pediatrician, agreed. "I have a lot of respect for what they are doing. But I'm concerned about the integration between the hospital, insurance and physicians.

"This integration is slowly but surely causing my practice to suffer," he said.

Story continues below
Newborn babies are the lifeblood of a pediatrician's practice, Armstrong said, and referrals are vital. But with only one, IHC-owned hospital in the Cache Valley and a policy to refer patients to IHC providers, the doctor said he is continually losing out on new patients.

"When you have a large predominant physician group that has strong internal referral processes, it makes it difficult for independent physicians to compete," Armstrong said.

Orthopaedic surgeon Terry Finlayson, also from Cache Valley, expressed similar concerns. IHC has flooded the area with physicians practicing in his field, who then get referrals from other members of IHC's physician and hospital network.

The company's control of patient flow in his area makes it impossible to compete on a level playing field, he said.

"We don't mind competing head-to-head with all other factors being equal . . . but there's no equality," Finlayson said.

Boorman agreed, saying he would have no problem losing patients to IHC physicians who offer a better product or service. But not, he said, "because they have plans that direct patients to them and give them an unfair advantage, especially in a closed community."

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Congrats to the George family, and to the larger Cougar family as well. ...

Watched the game with other RSL fans here in DC. I'm still reeling from this...

When I was going to college in the mid 70s I really enjoyed listening to...

It sounds like Boyd Peterson is keeping his father-in-law's memory alive....

Letters: Don Gale wrote truth

I am an old man, a conservative and life-long resident of Utah. For years I...

TCU creams U.

Can't we just say good job Utah and leave it at that. Does putting people...

Do they play 8 man or 6 man football anywere in Utah? Idaho used to have 11...

Tithes and offerings

I look forward to this time because I know we have been full tithe and fast...

Letters: Sodom and Gomorrah

Marvin, I know there's little or nothing I could ever do to change your mind...

Bennett is an OK guy, but he is not an effective leader or representative for...

Advertisements
Advertisement