From Deseret News archives:

Sen. Bennett outlines flag compromise

Published: Saturday, July 2, 2005 11:51 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WASHINGTON — Sen. Bob Bennett, R-Utah, has received his fair share of criticism for his opposition to a constitutional amendment to ban desecration of the American flag, an amendment sponsored in the Senate by Utah's other Republican senator, Orrin Hatch.

And through it all, Bennett has tried to make it crystal clear that he does not support flag burning. Rather, he just supports the constitutional rights of expression symbolized by flag.

"I wish to make it clear to my constituents and to others who have concern about this problem, that my objection to a constitutional amendment should not be construed as demonstrating indifference to the issue of reverence for the flag," he said Friday from the Senate floor.

And to demonstrate that commitment, Bennett on Friday introduced the Flag Protection Act, which criminalizes desecration or damage of the United States flag when a person does the damage with the primary purpose and intent to promote violence or breach the peace, when a person damages a flag belonging to the United States and when a person damages a flag belonging to another person.

All three provisions would pass constitutional muster, he said.

Bennett said he remains opposed to a constitutional amendment on flag desecration in part because he believes there just aren't enough cases to warrant tinkering with the Constitution.

Story continues below
"Flag desecration hit its peak during the Vietnam years, but it has virtually disappeared now and occurs, ironically, only when debate about the amendment to the Constitution becomes a subject of public discourse," Bennett said. "We seem to stimulate flag desecration when we have the debate on amending the Constitution to prevent it."

Bennett, with co-sponsor Kent Conrad, D-N.D., has introduced the legislation before, but it has never come to a vote.

Bennett quoted at length from editorials in the Deseret Morning News and the Salt Lake Tribune to make his point that the "Constitution is no place for feel-good amendments that do nothing but restrict freedoms.

"When my Senate career is over, I don't want the most important constitutional vote that I have cast to be one that weakens the First Amendment," he said.


E-mail: spang@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image

Sen. Bob Bennett, shown in 2004, still opposes a flag-desecration amendment.

previousnext

Latest comments

Happy Valley Heretic says "Besides it's not about what the people want, it's...

Ok, 1A teams you have to be good to be in the top 5. So, Liahona, Dugway,...

It's interesting that the colleges with the local talent are winning and the...

Watch out for Beaver as a longshot in 2a. They have the tradition and coaches...

Fall sports academic all-state

I agree! My daughter graduated 6th or 7th in her class but there was only...

Utes' Wynn in for awakening

Utefan, "...is it just another example of how Y-ners are like you are...

really? Nice call Einstein - good to know.

BYU would like friendlier rivalry

is believable!!! I've personally seen Utah fans sneeking into the stadium...

Expect epic clash on the line

Hey utmaniam Are you an English Major at the U. Get spell check. Better...

Letters: Trump card for believers

Sounds like someone is trying to move up in the corporation.

Advertisements