From Deseret News archives:
Justices' ruling favors cities in use of eminent domain
Utah Legislature limits will likely mitigate ruling
Some government officials and legal experts here called the 5-4 decision a huge blow to the U.S. property rights ideal; others said as a practical matter, the ruling won't mean much.
"Fair compensation" is still required for the seized property under the Fifth Amendment, which permits eminent domain to be imposed as long as it's for "public use." A majority of the court on Thursday concluded that public use was properly defined more broadly as "public purpose" and expanded it to include economic development.
Dissenting Justice Sandra Day O'Connor said the ruling expanded the power of "those citizens with disproportionate influence and power in the political process, including large corporations and development firms. Any property may now be taken for the benefit of another private party."
The court also, however, ruled that state legislators may tighten eminent-domain laws which Utah lawmakers did during this year's general session, stripping redevelopment agencies of any eminent-domain power.
Craig Call, with the state Department of Natural Resources and the state's only private-property ombudsman, believes the ruling makes private-property rights the "poor cousin" to other constitutional rights.
"It is significant," he said. "It marks a continual erosion of the protections that the courts are willing to offer" property owners.
"Nobody wants their mother moved out of a home of 60 years because they get more tax out of it," Call said.
That scenario probably won't happen in Utah, however, at least not until the Legislature changes the RDA laws to allow for eminent domain.
The RDA is "really the only economic development tool" cities can utilize, said Wilf Sommerkorn, director of community and economic development for Davis County.
Eminent domain was taken away under SB184, which also placed a one-year moratorium on RDAs for retail development and prohibited them for stadiums and other sports facilities.
While an RDA can still be developed if all sellers are willing, "it's very difficult to accomplish an RDA without eminent domain if you are dealing with multiple property owners," Sommerkorn said.
Comments
- Soccer MVPs know how to win 1:56 a.m.
- Alta's Ohai is Ms. Soccer 2009 1:56 a.m.
- High school soccer: Past MVPs 1:37 a.m.
- Senators want food tax restored 1:27 a.m.
- Utah women lag in higher education 1:16 a.m.
- Hatch empathizes with Muslims 1:14 a.m.
- Matheson gets no thanks from GOP 1:13 a.m.
- Mitchell seeks to block witnesses 1:12 a.m.
- Party insiders may take on Bennett 1:11 a.m.
- Input sought on nondiscrimination 1:11 a.m.
- TCU showdown has big implications
- Seniors helped BYU regroup
- Lambert surprisingly tops news
- Bystanders framed for child porn
- Hope for single moms
- Soccer MVPs know how to win
- Korver and Miles to be evaluated
- Matheson gets no thanks from GOP
- Utah Jazz Extra: Whose hot/not
- Newhouse Hotel, an explosive end
- House passes health care bill
228 - TCU showdown has big implications
183 - Lobo suspended
182 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
154 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
131 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
118 - Thousands protest health bill
114 - RSL rallies to advance
103 - No 'backlash' for pioneers, gays analogy
97 - Utes pound winless Lobos
89
Meghan McCain, the daughter of former presidential candidate John...
Why do so many people live so close to refineries in Utah and elsewhere?
Sounds like a good option if you can't or won't switch to AT&T for the...
I worked with and around Bill Sederburg for 5 years while he was at...
hand. He needs to work on his moves to the basket and rebounding. Lateral...
play Fez or Koufos tonight. He went with a smaller line up and Boozer, Okur...
I've met Bennett before and he is a nice man. He also knows the Constitution...
That's never been a secret. Everyone will pay for it except those that don't...
I agree with NonMormon. I am active LDS, and I enjoy Ash's articles, and I...
I kept saying don't resign Milsap, especially after Portland offered that...
BYU is the slowest team that has ever been in the top 25. Utah will put up a...
i think u have the cowboys ranked too low! at least an A- LOL nice work!


You can be the first to comment on this story.