From Deseret News archives:
Justices consider who controls workers fund
State says lower court erred in ruling on its ownership
The hearing resulted from a long-standing legal battle over whether the WCF, which provides insurance for workers who are injured on the job, is under state control as a state agency, or if it should be considered a private corporation doing public service.
The state claims a lower district court erred when it ruled the state has no more ownership interest in WCF than any of the fund's 30,000 policy holders.
During oral arguments, Assistant Attorney General Thom Roberts said there were some serious constitutional questions over whether the state can create a private corporation.
Mark Hindley, attorney for WCF, argued several Supreme Court rulings already have established the insurance company as an independent and quasi-private corporation that receives no money from the state. In one such ruling in 1977, the high court ruled the Utah Legislature had no right to take money from the WCF injury fund to cover budgetary shortfalls in other state agencies. The fund is paid into by Utah employers who, by law, must provide insurance for their workers.
Driven by its desire to distance the state from quasi-governmental corporations after the thrift and loan debacle in the late 1980s, the Legislature in 1988 designated the WCF a quasi-public corporation.
But Roberts countered that the WCF cannot deny its government ties. He pointed to the fact that when WCF applied for a federal tax exemption with the IRS, it claimed it was providing a "government function" in being the carrier of last resort (which means when no other private insurance company will offer an employer insurance, WCF must provide coverage).
WCF officials counter that by taking the burden of carrier of last resort, a tax break is justified but that hardly means WCF is a governmental agency.
Roberts also pointed to WCF's dissolution charter, which states that if the insurance fund were to ever fold, all assets would go to the state.
But justices questioned why the state was drawing such a black-and-white argument. Chief Justice Christine Durham said there are plenty of quasi-government corporations which function outside the state's control yet provide a public service.
Durham said the state, by law, cannot take over the assets of a county, school district or water district just because they are quasi-governmental in nature.
Hindley said in the world of corporate law, control and ownership issues are not simple. He said WCF is simply a trustee of the injury fund and does not see itself as the owner, but rather the individual policy holders are its owners.
The court is expected to issue a ruling in the following weeks.
E-mail: gfattah@desnews.com
Comments
- New offerings from past winners 12:50 p.m.
- Make a pilgrim to celebrate season 12:46 p.m.
- Mauer is American League MVP 12:38 p.m.
- A holiday with the (price) trImmings 12:38 p.m.
- Kimbo Slice to make UFC debut 12:36 p.m.
- NPR newscaster Carl Kasell to retire 12:34 p.m.
- Jackson's doctor returns to work 12:33 p.m.
- Stocks higher on home sales data 12:32 p.m.
- Gosselin divorce could be final soon 12:31 p.m.
- Fox CEO wants US to join France 12:30 p.m.
- Buttars wants to limit gay rights laws
212 - Glenn Beck to enter politics?
205 - Palin plans tour stop in Utah
178 - RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks
176 - BYU records with win
132 - Palin's book shows she's unqualified
129 - Officer cleared in Cardall Taser case
103 - BYU cuts Women's Research Inst.
102 - Jazz finally win in San Antonio
99 - Utes knock off rival Aggies
93
A survey by Accountemps says that this year, fewer people plan to shop...
A little after midnight Wednesday morning, about 21 hours ago as I write...
Earl specifically calls out the Gay Pride Parade in San Francisco. The...
The problem is the clear. Health care costs are too high. The solution is...
are not Hall and Johnson. They are the BYU O line vs the Utah D, the BYU play...
These guys look like real winners!
Anonymous | 11:14 a.m. I forgot to remind you that you CLAIM to be all...
While I agree that the kiss in as you discripe it would be a bad idea I may I...
Boozer and Olur played great defense against the Spurs. They can get it...
They'd better not because a sub .500 regular season for the Jazz would keep...
What many fail to understand is that the as an active Latter Day Saint I do...
RONALD REAGAN: THE ANNOINTED ONE Thanks for the memories; While MEN his...


You can be the first to comment on this story.