From Deseret News archives:

Utah's non-war over evolution

It's taught — but probably not believed

Published: Friday, March 18, 2005 6:18 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Anxious e-mails have been filling Karlene Bauer's inbox this school year — messages about Cobb County, Ga., and Dover, Pa., and all the other places where people are up in arms over the teaching of evolution.

Bauer, who teaches at Jordan High School and is on a listserv of AP biology teachers across the country, says she's happy to be in Utah, where Darwin's 146-year-old theory is currently making neither waves nor headlines.

One might suppose, given that Utahns tend to be both conservative and religious, that evolution would be a contentious topic in Utah's schools; but yet another legislative session has passed with no mention of Charles Darwin. And Brett Moulding can count on his fingers the number of anti-evolution phone calls he's gotten in the past 10 years, first as science education specialist and then as curriculum director for the Utah State Office of Education.

As Murray high biology teacher Steve Scheidell says, "It's not a thing to panic about here."

That may be because not all biology teachers in Utah tackle the touchiest part of evolutionary theory: how humans came to be. And Utah students often don't believe what they've been taught anyway, because they've learned something different from teachers in LDS Church seminary classes.

Story continues below
As a whole, Utahns tend to be conflicted about the intersection of evolution and public education. A Dan Jones Deseret Morning News/KSL-TV poll conducted last week found that 64 percent of Utahns think evolution should be taught in biology classes — and 70 percent think creationism, "Intelligent Design" and other belief systems should be taught there too.

It is this desire for equal class time for Darwin and "alternative theories" that has set off the latest battles in America's 80-year-old evolution wars, whose most famous early skirmish was the 1925 trial and conviction (later overturned) of Tennessee teacher John Scopes, who tried to teach evolutionary theory. In 1987, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that a Louisiana law requiring equal treatment of evolution and "creation science" was an unconstitutional violation of the First Amendment, but that has hardly been the end of the friction.

The National Center for Science Education, a pro-evolution organization based in California, reports that eight state legislatures have considered evolution bills this year; and there have been "33 incidents of significant anti-evolution activity in local communities in 15 states." In many of these cases, anti-evolutionists are pulling out the "academic freedom" card, arguing that their First Amendment rights are being trampled if alternative theories aren't discussed in the classroom.

Recent comments

Although I currently live in NC, I grew up in SLC and learned about...

mary | Nov. 5, 2007 at 7:01 a.m.

Image
Photo illustration by Jessica Noel Berry, Deseret Morning News

previousnext

Latest comments

" Gay marriage is only immoral in certain religions" So that makes it...

SLC council OKs gay rights policies

To Mark at 10:20, Kalamazoo just passed its anti-discrimination ordinace...

Re: More to Denny G: You also have to get past a great coaching staff that...

the "truth" is that if you are a conservative and do not have the facts on...

If we aren't going to play D, then we might as well be Phoenix. At least they...

2A: Broncos vs. Wildcats

Just hang on the travel issue all you want. If thats the only thing you can...

Letters: Trash or truth?

TO "Dr. Adrenaline | 11:10 a.m." but Obama, Pelosi, and Reid all use the same...

Look, I am a Utah man and I am very proud of what they accomplished over the...

Sloan may toy with starting lineup

DID NOT re-sign Brewer for what he was asking. Can you hear that in the...

Utes remain silent about BCS

Utah will lose to TCU and BYU and will be invited to the Bow Tidley Tech bowl...

Advertisements
Advertisement