From Deseret News archives:

Street protester bill yanked

Would have cut access to church, medical buildings

Published: Thursday, Feb. 24, 2005 8:04 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
A bill aimed at protesting street preachers who congregate outside Temple Square during LDS General Conference is going "the way of the wind," according to the lawmaker who sponsored it.

HB131 used the language of a controversial Colorado law aimed at restricting anti-abortion activists outside clinics to keep street preachers from approaching people outside places of worship.

On the House floor Thursday, Rep. Doug Aagard, R-Kaysville, announced he was withdrawing his "Access to Health Care Facilities and Places of Worship" bill from consideration.

"It's going away with the wind," Aagard told the Deseret Morning News. Aagard said his main purpose for the bill was to get the attention of street preachers and hold them criminally and civilly accountable for any harassment.

The bill would have made it unlawful for any protester to approach within 8 feet of a person for the purpose of passing a leaflet, displaying a sign or engaging in conversation. Protesters would also have been limited to no more than 100 feet from the entrance of any medical facility or place of worship. Not only would the bill have made the offense of this law a class-B misdemeanor but also would have allowed the person harassed to sue for civil damages.

Story continues below
The bill certainly did get the preachers' attention, as one attorney representing them said they would have taken legal action against the state had the bill passed into law, citing serious constitutional concerns.

Anti-abortion protestors in Colorado took that state's version of the law to the U.S. Supreme Court, which upheld the law as constitutional, citing that women seeking abortion counseling at a clinic have a right against harassment, given that the subject was such a difficult and personal decision.

Although the Supreme Court upheld the language for clinics, the same could not be said if applied to places of worship, said attorney Randall Wenger, who represents a group of street preachers.

Aagard said he pulled the bill due to some unresolved issues with it but would not say what those were. However, he did say there is a possibility that he will reintroduce the bill during next year's legislative session.


E-mail: gfattah@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Jeremy Harmon, Deseret Morning News

Street preacher Ruben Israel gestures to the "Got hate?" sign held by Gary Nelson in an exchange outside the LDS Church's Conference Center in 2004.

previousnext

Latest comments

2A: Broncos vs. Wildcats

Broncos STATE CHAMPS your hard work paid off. Thanks for giving us fans a fun...

Rep. bashes Dems over health care

WASHINGTON – The government paid more than $47 billion in questionable...

No. 22 BYU holds off pesky Lobos

I just hope the UTES play as well against TCU as BYU played against TCU.

goodness nothing serious happened to the Nelsons....

God bless Brother and Sister Nelson. I'm thankful that they were okay.

Am. Fork band hopes for nationals

I am a sixth generation cavemen... meaning i am in the 6th gen. of my family...

BYU fans, let's celebrate the win and ignore ute fans. They are just jealous...

"the edge goes to BYU, who has been more impressive over more similar...

GameDay in Fort Worth

Barry Switzer also said that none of the players on Utah's roster would ever...

First off he missed 3 field goals, not 2. BYU fans are so so so hilarious to...

Advertisements
Advertisement