From Deseret News archives:

Justice for victims?

Babies and tiny children dead; those entrusted with their care are accused

Published: Monday, April 25, 2005 10:07 a.m. MDT
PRINT | FONT + - 
A Deseret Morning News search of court records and newspaper archives identified 36 children younger than 6 who died as a result of child-abuse related homicide since 1999.

Twenty-three victims were boys; 13 were girls. Among those who were charged with crimes are 25 men and 13 women. In two cases, both parents were charged. Fourteen fathers and seven mothers were accused of killing their biological or adopted sons or daughters.

But there may be many more child-homicide cases that have gone undocumented.

Prosecutors in Salt Lake, Davis, Weber and Utah counties were unable to say how many potential cases they screen for charges but, for various reasons, do not file any charges. None of them track that information.

"We don't file every case that comes to us a possible homicide," Deputy Salt Lake District Attorney Jim Cope said. "I couldn't tell you if it is 3 percent or 30 percent that we get rid of."

Cope conceded that sometimes prosecutors may take the easy way out. "I think justice is being done in the cases that we bring," he said. "I think there are some people who have quote 'gotten away with murder.' "

Weber County

Victim: Karston Sampson, 17 months

Died: Jan. 29, 1999

How died: Shaken baby syndrome

Evidence: Pre-existing medical condition complicated case

Accused: Justin Jay Scott, mother's boyfriend

Charge: Murder

Outcome: Scott entered an "Alford plea"* to second-degree child abuse homicide; 2nd District Judge Parley Baldwin sentenced Scott to 30 days in jail.

Victim: Isaac Austin, 4 months

Died: Feb. 10, 2001

How died: Beating, shaking

Evidence: Lacerated liver, 16 broken ribs and head injury

Accused: John L. Austin, baby's father

Charge: Capital homicide

Outcome: Austin pleaded guilty to lesser charge of first-degree murder; 4th District Judge Brent West sentenced Austin to five years to life. His first parole hearing is scheduled for 2016.


Victim: Nathan Scheer, 6 months

Died: May 11, 2001

How died: Suffocation

Evidence: Mother confessed to smothering child with a plastic bag, a pile of blankets and her hand.

Accused: Jennifer Robinson, mother

Charge: Murder; attempted murder, second-degree felony

Outcome: Pleaded guilty but mentally ill to murder; 2nd District Judge Stanton Taylor ordered five years to life in prison.


Victim: Schaedie Jaedin Bolan, 19 months

Died: May 26, 2001

How died: Shaking

Accused: Derek Byron West, baby sitter

Charge: Murder

Outcome: Pleaded guilty to lesser charge of child abuse homicide, second-degree felony; 2nd District Judge Roger S. Dutson ordered one to 15 years in prison.


Victim: Jacob Best, 11 months

Died: July 16, 2002

How died: Beating, shaking

About this ad

View Comments

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.

– About Comments

rss icon

Recommended in Utah

Story

A once vibrant 14-year-old is often too sick to get out of bed. Her health has been like that for nearly two years.

Story

Celebrating the 10th anniversary of the Salt Lake Olympics gives everyone a chance to remember.

Story

A Salt Lake City couple is working to ensure safety improvements are made at a dangerous intersection.

In News Across Site

No. Utah sees a major earthquake every 350 years. Last one? 350 years ago.