From Deseret News archives:

MBC wins an appeal against Microsoft

Published: Thursday, Dec. 30, 2004 10:17 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The U.S. 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver has struck down a lower court's decision ordering a Utah company to pay nearly $2 million in damages to tech giant Microsoft.

Microsoft, based in Redmond, Wash., claims that Salt Lake-based MBC Enterprises purchased and sold counterfeit Microsoft Windows 98, Office and Microsoft NT Server software.

According to court documents, the lower court awarded Microsoft nearly $2 million in statutory damages for copyright and trademark infringement and issued a permanent injunction against MBC Enterprises, prohibiting the company from engaging in business activities related to Microsoft software.

However, the 10th Circuit Court reversed the lower court's grant of summary judgment in favor of Microsoft, dismissing monetary damages and the permanent injunction.

"We conclude there are genuine issues of material fact that preclude the entry of summary judgment," the 10th Circuit Court said in an order this week. "No counterfeit units of software were found during a search of MBC's offices, and there is no evidence of counterfeit software being obtained from any of MBC's customers."

Calls seeking comment from Microsoft and MBC Enterprises were not immediately returned to the Deseret Morning News Thursday.

Story continues below
Two counterfeit units of Windows NT Server software were found in the possession of a Michigan-based company that allegedly purchased the software from MBC. But the 10th Circuit Court said the lower court erred in concluding that the two counterfeit units came from MBC.

Further, the 10th Circuit Court said that even assuming a Texas-based company had sold counterfeit units of software to MBC, "Microsoft points to no specific evidence that MBC actually resold that software."

The case was remanded for further proceedings.


E-mail: danderton@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Thurl Bailey's wonderful life

Thurl i just saw you in person lol you went to my brothers school, Riverview...

Cougars land Vegas standout

Actually, ASU offered Collinsworth and wanted him very badly. So the score is...

It would be interesting to know how religiosity modifies the results if at...

GO TIMPVIEW 38-21!! I Guess trash talk only gets you so far..

Even the TDS fans can appreciate this. I think a mountain west team has been...

House passes health care bill

Got me there :) Dr shortage in Japan. They still have the option of opening...

Should districts pay union reps?

The concept is too crazy to deserve comment.

Utes remain silent about BCS

Over-rated. The fact that the y was ever rated in the top 20 this or last...

4A: Springville holds off Dixie

Any coach can tell you that there is something to be said about having your...

Up to $1 million dollars for economic impact for this estimated gross imapct...

Advertisements
Advertisement