From Deseret News archives:

Utahns open up on 'divide'

Goal of forum is to bridge state's religion-based split

Published: Thursday, Nov. 18, 2004 9:23 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
A Muslim man named Abdul said he lived in many nations before coming to Salt Lake City and finding LDS family values mirrored his own Islamic values quite well. He encouraged kindness and compassion as bridges to understanding.

Wesley Smith said he recently returned to live in Park City after 20 years outside Utah and realized "this state is in trouble," even in his mountain community. He urged residents to choose their language carefully, noting that as a conservative, he is turned off by talk of "tolerance" as a buzz word for liberal ideas rather than a term of social acceptance.

Cheryl Pace said she is Protestant but has LDS in-laws and respects them greatly. Yet the "political reality is the majority of power is in one place . . . The solution to that doesn't seem to be tolerance . . . They are afraid of losing their power and I'm afraid of never getting any . . . The real elephant in the room is that the majority rules."

Story continues below
Rob Latham said Utah's "winner-take-all" elective power structure ensures that the majority will be over-represented and the minority will have little voice. He suggested reshaping the way Utahns elect leaders by instituting a proportional representation system. "If you get 60 percent of the vote (by party) you get 60 percent of the seats" in the state legislature or municipal governments. He said the system works well in Cambridge, MA, and would level the playing field in Utah.

The biggest applause of the evening went to a man named Bart, who said he wants to be able to buy full-strength beer in places other than state-run liquor stores and doesn't want to line up for an arm band to get a brew at sporting events. He's also concerned about the effect LDS seminaries have on students who use religious smugness to ostracize their peers. "I'm so happy I said what I said," he grinned. "I can't believe I did it."

A Jewish man who came to Utah only three weeks ago told of conversing with LDS missionaries on Temple Square. "I'm not going to join," he said, but he enjoyed learning about the faith and encouraged others to simply ask about beliefs other than their own.

Jack Gallivan, who identified himself as a "sixth-generation Roman Catholic, a minority, and a frustrated beer drinker," said he believes the religious divide can be overcome only if the First Presidency of the LDS Church issues a declaration instructing members to teach their children to "respect all other faiths in the spirit Jesus taught in loving our neighbor." If Latter-day Saints would adhere to such instruction, he said, "the divide could be bridged in a generation or less."

Katherine Nelson grew up LDS in Australia where she tried to hide her faith for fear of persecution. Once she moved to New Jersey, she experienced a freedom to live her faith in a way she hadn't known before. So she was troubled to hear a new neighbor here tell her how much she would love the neighborhood because "there aren't many Mormons here. If we put the word 'Jew' or 'black' in that sentence instead, we all would be horrified.

"I think the problem is in our hearts and can only be changed by love," she said.


E-mail: carrie@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image

Salt Lake Mayor Rocky Anderson, lower left, laughs as Wesley Smith of Park City takes a turn at the open mike at Wednesday night's "Bridging the Religious Divide" forum.

previousnext

Latest comments

GREAT WIN!! Beating the cougs felt great! Listening to Jimmer Fredette's post...

Sloan gets 1-year extension

has risks, but not switching coaches tends to limit any chance Utah has of...

We are praying for the Vigil family. The Clawson's

Why is Y. ignoring spew of hatred?

It doesn't look like BYU does have a higher standard.

Hate not limited to 1 in-state rivalry

"They can’t figure out why people outside their bubble don’t like...

A matter of rivalry or persecution?

Personally.. I think that it is time to do away with this game between Utah...

Equality Utah official resigns

So, did Mr. Carlson represent Equality Utah in negotiations with Salt Lake...

I know this will sting, Aggies, but this game was the Aggie superbowl. it's...

I'm glad the judge didn't allow him bail. I'm so sick of all of these...

Our Prayers are with the Vigil family.

Advertisements