From Deseret News archives:

Voter, beware of polls disguised as the truth

Published: Sunday, Oct. 10, 2004 12:21 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The Tribune's departure from tradition is significant because media outlets always utilize their own political analysis because they control the quality of methodology, questions, respondents etc. Polls conducted by campaigns can be easily manipulated (shocking!) and are usually rejected by reporters. Realizing the Deseret Morning News was about to print their poll, the Tribune was forced to run the story on Wednesday. Politicos noted the Tribune did not perform the standard feature of providing dates when the survey was conducted, verifying the Matheson poll had prompted the Tribune to stall.

The Deseret Morning News poll, conducted by the well-respected Dan Jones, shows Huntsman leading by 9 points. Because of his enormous local polling experience, most authorities believe Jones is closer to the mark. Thus, Huntsman is leading, but the gubernatorial election is still up for grabs.

Webb: Weird Polls. For better or for worse, survey research is becoming a bigger part of campaigns and news media political coverage in every election cycle. We're inundated by polls and, as Frank suggests, we've recently witnessed some pretty strange survey numbers.

The three recent gubernatorial polls, showing wildly divergent results, obviously can't all be accurate. The Tribune poll, done by Valley Research, gave Huntsman a 16-point lead. On the other extreme, the candidates were dead even, 42-42, in the Matheson campaign poll, done by GarinHartYang. That's a hefty difference. The Morning News' Dan Jones & Associates survey came out in the middle, with Huntsman up nine points.

Story continues below
So who is right? I 'd throw out both polls on the extremes and go with Jones. The Hart poll had some strange wrinkles, and sometimes out-of-state firms, even good ones, don't understand Utah political nuances, and they draw a bad sample.

The Valley Research Poll is hard to figure. Another question on the same survey had Initiative 1 losing, while at least three other polls have shown the initiative ahead by wide margins. (Disclosure: My firm, the Exoro Group, is supporting the initiative.) I don't believe either the Tribune or Valley Research was trying to skew anything, but I wouldn't trust that particular poll.

Any survey is just a snapshot in time, and circumstances can change quickly. Voters need to be smart consumers of political news, including survey results. Read widely, don't accept everything at face value, and consult with people you trust.

County Mayor. The final three weeks in the county mayoral race will be great political theater. Democrat Peter Corroon, by default as much as anything else, is clearly the frontrunner at this point, even though he hasn't defined himself very well. Republicans have their white knight in Ellis Ivory, but he's dragging a big weight into battle in the form of Nancy Workman.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

no one can do any thing vs ben lomond we are 2-0 If we play like this the...

Colombian Mormon denied asylum

Dear Sick and Tired, You are an idiot. If you actually took the time to...

i like the baby blue jerseys! way better than the dark blue jerseys!

Homeless keep their focus on family

i have no family who can help so regardless if i have a place to stay or not...

"Mormons don't even celebrate advent. What is up with this?" There's...

He just does not have good basketball instincts. I know this is his first...

Ed Smart infuriated with revelations

To the 5:04 comentator, This is a FEDERAL prosecution. It is the entire...

Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing

Skousen and Beck? What an utter embarassment! THe fact that we have a panel...

I'm a little surprised by this choice of all-staters. I thought for sure San...

I find it strange when folks suggest that Atheism is a religion of its own....

Advertisements