From Deseret News archives:

Attorneys spar — then Workman hearing is set

Published: Tuesday, Sept. 21, 2004 12:36 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Salt Lake County Mayor Nancy Workman will get her chance next week to prove her case should be prosecuted by somebody other than special prosecutor Mike Martinez.

Lawyers in the case sparred in court Monday over Workman's motion to dismiss, Martinez's request for a gag order, whether to hold a preliminary hearing — further delaying the trial — and even moving the trial somewhere else.

A hearing on both motions will be held Sept. 30.

Workman, who is on a forced leave of absence until the case is adjudicated, is charged with two counts of misusing public funds, one a second-degree felony and the other a third-degree felony.

Jack Morgan, one of her lawyers, filed a motion to get the case dismissed last week because of negative comments Martinez has made regarding her, as well as the fact that Martinez represents criminal defendants — a possible impermissible conflict.

For his part, Martinez maintains Workman is trying to taint the jury pool with political advertisements saying the case is "just politics" and wants 3rd District Judge Robert Hilder to silence her with a gag order.

Story continues below
Hilder, who set Sept. 30 as a hearing date for both motions, is clearly amenable to moving things along. He called for Monday's hearing and pushed Martinez to withdraw his objection to the waiver of a preliminary hearing.

Martinez said he will agree to waiving the Oct. 4 hearing only if Workman acknowledges in writing that he has probable cause to bring the case.

Morgan said such a statement is not legally required for a waiver and that Workman would be making "a mini guilty plea" by doing so.

Hilder, who appeared slightly exasperated by the bickering over what he clearly saw as details, told Morgan to come up with a written statement by Workman and for Martinez to vet it.

"Don't you think you can trust the court to decide that?" Hilder asked when Martinez objected to the possible wording of the statement. "I do this every day."

Workman, a Republican seeking re-election, is eager to get her case resolved before the general election. Her lawyers insist the special prosecutor is deliberately creating delays because he was appointed by and is aligned with Salt Lake County District Attorney David Yocom, a Democrat.

"The problem with this case is that it's bending the rules for someone who thinks they have some special privilege and do not have to wait in line," Martinez said outside the courtroom.

As for Workman, her camp maintains that it is in voters' interest to have the case adjudicated one way or another by Nov. 2 so they can make an informed decision.

In his motion for a restraining order asking that the parties not discuss the case "with third parties outside the courtroom," Martinez said Workman and her lawyers are "employing a strategy designed to influence potential jurors through disparagement of the judicial process."

In response to the request for a gag order, Morgan said all parties in criminal cases are free, within limits, to exercise their free speech. "A gag order is a very bad idea in any case," he said. "Especially this case."


E-mail: lindat@desnews.com; aedwards@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

2 stranded hikers rescued

I enjoy the outdoors. I'm in my late 40s and in better shape than most men...

Wounded Utes limp home

Utah goes to the Las Vegas bowl on off years, BYU goes there on good years.

MWC expand? Get rid of deadweight

Mike Sorenson assumes a lot will change in the college football landscape to...

Letters: Utah not all rosy

The first thing you need to learn is that nobody can GIVE you happiness. It...

Costly mistakes doomed Utes

Whittingham really needs to do something about turnovers and penalties. They...

Adding truth serum to her cereal

The deception of the cereal makers is almost as blatant and laughable as the...

"He was such a good missionary. I don't know what happened." He had...

Fedor was right, this is our year. I was suprised Chiacgo came out so...

Barzee to plead guilty

RE Jacob Baker - Yeah.. they caught her a looong time ago. Time to bone up on...

would have been a much better player had he gone to a good college program,...

Advertisements
Advertisement