From Deseret News archives:

Draft is government confiscation of labor

Published: Tuesday, May 4, 2004 6:42 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Being employed producing the hardware for the defense of our country need not be voluntary. The government could send us draft notices ordering us to report for work at General Dynamics' Texas track-vehicle facility at $400 a month. If the government did this, would you call it a draft or slave labor? Not to worry, the Defense Department offers attractive contracts to firms like McDonnell Douglas and General Dynamics, and they in turn offer attractive wages to employees, and thus, voluntarism gets the right number of workers to make the right number of jets and tanks.

The Defense Department might argue that a draft is needed, because it would be too expensive to pay market wages to get the desired number of soldiers. It would be right so far as the military budget is concerned but wrong when it comes to military's true cost to the nation. The true cost of a soldier in the army is the value of what he could have produced, and society must sacrifice, were he not in the army — what economists call "opportunity cost." Even if the military paid the soldier nothing, the nation must forgo what the soldier could have produced were he not in the military.

National defense is an important government function; for rational decision-making, we mustn't permit concealment of its cost through measures like the draft.


Creators Syndicate

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

I'm stoked about this weather!! Let it snow and let it snow hard!! This 4...

I'm all for reducing our oil dependence. I'm all for cleaning up pollution...

West side hoop fan west Jordan cheetahs will be put to sleep tonight by with...

Russell stares down fake Jordan

errrrr Mr. Bryant Anderson. Give us your real identity . . . sitting by your...

Letters: Global warming a lie

You never question the motives of your news sources that are very carefull to...

hey jack Fids, We live in a Representative Republic, not a true Democracy....

Yet again, we learn BCS is a big joke

Which high school did you NOT graduate from? You have been reading between...

Revive full food tax?

How about we tax the legislature every time they think about raising taxes....

Dr.: Mitchell seeks signs from God

Does he understand that what he did was illegal? Can he understand what's...

"The US has been responsible for phenomenal good in the world. But not in our...

Advertisements