From Deseret News archives:

'Spyware' bill would hurt Net use

Published: Friday, March 19, 2004 7:14 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
While consumer protection authorities like the Federal Trade Commission and key committees of the Congress carefully examine the issues surrounding so-called "spyware," last week the Utah Legislature became the first to pass a law on the subject, HB323.

Despite the well-placed intentions of the bill's sponsors, unfortunately, HB323 would have serious unintended consequences on everyday, legitimate activities on the Internet. These activities include, for example, use of software that consumers depend on to ensure a positive and safe experience in their shopping and e-commerce transactions and tools that combat fraud and theft over the Internet.

Gov. Walker is deciding now whether to let the bill become law or veto it. The best step for Gov. Walker to take is to veto the bill and ask that all the key parties sit down to come up with a focused, less controversial approach.

What few legislators probably realized at the time of the vote is that rather than curtailing the bad spyware, the bill in its current form could potentially criminalize some of the most popular consumer software on the market, including popular media players, anti-virus programs, Internet services, e-mail programs, and networking software. An even greater irony: Some of the most effective anti-spyware software solutions available today could potentially be outlawed by this "anti-spyware" legislation.

Story continues below
Over the past 12 years, Govs. Walker and Leavitt have worked very hard to make Utah an attractive place for Internet and software companies to locate and do business. And Internet companies have responded by investing in Utah and employing people.

The American Electronics Association estimates that in 2002 Utah ranked 13th in the country with more than 5,000 jobs in software development and more than 50,000 tech jobs. A study by Nathan Associates, done for the Business Software Alliance, estimates that the software industry and the jobs it generated contributed $134 million in state taxes to Utah in 2002. HB323 would send an entirely different signal.

Innovative software and e-commerce companies, many of whom are adversely impacted by technologies labeled as so-called "spyware," would have to think very hard about innovating and giving consumers interactive, seamless software that makes use of the Internet easy and engaging. They would also have to bury consumers with notices about details of the way that current software works.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

I'm pretty sure you can be excited about the team without getting carried...

I would like to take a moment and thank all of our veterans for their...

SLC council OKs gay rights policies

Repeating a lie does make it true, no matter how often you repeat the lie....

Wow, there are a lot of LDS church haters out there. I am sure it helps them...

AMA: repeal 'don't ask,don't tell'

wait I thought it was people like you that always claim that the majority if...

Letters: Cougars weren't angels

First: I agree. The response of the New Mexico player was over the line....

Williams' back 'worse,' Price out

but it may be worth a try. Start Maynor a PG and AK at 2, move Brewer to 3....

Civilians help S.L. officer make arrest

shoot the guy in the leg, that'll stop him. We've started to treat CRIMINALS...

What was interesting was that in SLC, the LDS Church didn't just remain...

12 Utes return to Texas

The only real difference is dedication!! In Texas, Florida, and California...

Advertisements
Advertisement