From Deseret News archives:
'Fighting words' may not apply to crowds
S.L. attorneys say insulting masses is legal in U.S.
Instead, the so-called fighting words doctrine, established by the U.S. Supreme Court and other federal courts, applies only to individuals, or, at most, small groups of no more than four, city attorneys told the council this week.
So, while some Salt Lake City leaders would like to restrain anti-LDS street preaching during The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints' annual general conference next month, they likely won't be able to because preachers generally address large crowds.
For example, if a street preacher made a general statement saying "LDS women are harlots" as one reportedly did to a crowd of people walking by, that would be OK under federal courts' interpretation of the First Amendment. However, if a street preacher singled out a single woman and called her a harlot, that wouldn't be considered free speech and would violate the city's laws banning words that are "inherently likely to cause a violent reaction."
While city attorneys at Mayor Rocky Anderson's request recommended this week that the city expand its definitions of fighting "words" to include actions, gestures and displays also, those same attorneys said that expansion would have no effect on crowd speech.
If free speech changes have little or no effect on street preachers at conference, some council members wondered why the city is expanding its ordinances at all.
"What does this prohibit that now is not prohibited?" councilman Dave Buhler asked. "To me it really changes nothing."
City Attorney Ed Rutan conceded the ordinance change was minor in application.
Anderson had asked the city attorneys office to examine the city's free speech laws after two skirmishes between street preachers and conference attendees last October. During the review, the LDS Church had submitted public comment suggesting buffer zones between preachers and conferencegoers.
Dale Lambert, the only attorney on the council, said this week he disagreed with City Attorney Ed Rutan and Deputy Attorney Boyd Ferguson's interpretation of case law. Lambert said fighting words could apply to groups.
For example, someone yelling "fire" in a crowded theater wouldn't be protected speech, and it is aimed at a group. If that "group" speech isn't protected, Lambert said he wondered why fighting words aimed a group should be protected.
"In the whole area of First Amendment and free speech and religious speech laws there are so many cases to get clear and bright line tests, that's pretty difficult to do," he said.
But Ferguson and Rutan insist there is clearly defined case law stating that fighting words cannot be directed at groups and conceded the ordinance change was minor in application.
"We did view it more as a clarification than any major change," he said.
E-mail: bsnyder@desnews.com
Comments
- T-giving weekend, minus Skins Game 2:33 p.m.
- Antarctic icebergs head for N.Zealand 2:30 p.m.
- Rates could feed speculative bubble 2:25 p.m.
- Teams still alive for BCS at-large bids 2:21 p.m.
- Woman describes stabbing, killing 2:05 p.m.
- Stocks retreat on reports 1:45 p.m.
- Bills consider Shanahan for coach 1:42 p.m.
- Mitchell's attorneys file to withdraw 1:29 p.m.
- King Kong figurine sold in UK 1:01 p.m.
- Turkey tips from experts 12:59 p.m.
- Protests against Phoenix LDS temple
- Utah, BYU are top choices for bowls
- BYU's Lamb, Jorgensen reprimanded
- BYU would like friendlier rivalry
- Best prep football games of 2009
- KSL: Prostitution in Utah County
- Man trapped in own body for 23 yrs
- Kirilenko climbing blocks list
- 'Dancing' will fill out finale
- Boys basketball rankings
- Glenn Beck to enter politics?
220 - RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks
202 - Palin plans tour stop in Utah
178 - BYU would like friendlier rivalry
162 - Protests against Phoenix LDS temple
157 - Bronco, Kyle rubber match
136 - Palin's book shows she's unqualified
134 - BYU records with win
132 - BYU cuts Women's Research Inst.
103 - Officer cleared in Cardall Taser case
103
How many times have we heard this? True it is your time to shine, but will...
Our politicians want power and to stay in power and all the perks that come...
Watch those computer rankings next Sunday, I think you'll have a problem...
use something like a football rivalry to excuse behavioral deficiencies like...
In this article it is implied that BYU is going to win. You read it. I just...
How could any lawyer live with him/herself after defending such a jack!!!!...
who writes "If you are TRULY faithful, then there is no question to where ANY...
In Switzerland, healthcare is still less expensive at 11.6% of GDP vs. 15.3%...
Lets hope that these three players are used frequently during the rivalry...
BYU- 37 Utah- 17



You can be the first to comment on this story.