From Deseret News archives:

Gay unions ruled legal

Utah aims to blunt Massachusetts decision

Published: Tuesday, Nov. 18, 2003 11:25 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled 4-3 Tuesday that the state's ban on same-sex marriage is unconstitutional and gave lawmakers 180 days to come up with a solution that would allow gay couples to wed.

The court did not issue marriage licenses to the seven couples who sued and left the details to the Massachusetts Legislature.

Utah legislators will quickly try to blunt any move here to recognize same-sex marriages performed in Massachusetts.

State Sen. Chris Buttars, R-West Jordan, will introduce a bill in the 2004 Legislature that clearly says Utah recognizes a marriage only between one man and one woman.

Massachusetts "can do what it wants. This is the best way for (Utah) to deal with this," Buttars said Tuesday.

He expects his bill to pass "by a large margin."

But a new law won't prevent what Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff anticipates will be "a flood" of lawsuits.

It will be "no time before a (same-sex) couple comes back to Utah" with a Massachusetts marriage license and sues to be recognized here, Shurtleff said.

Rep. Jackie Biskupski, D-Salt Lake, said Buttars is right in believing the Utah Legislature will quickly adopt his bill.

"The bill will pass, I'm sure, unfortunately so," said Biskupski, who is gay. She called Buttars' proposal mean- spirited and unconstitutional.

Story continues below
Biskupski said she's seen a draft bill that has a section that would prohibit lawsuits by gays wishing to clarify their legal standing. "It's ludicrous to try to keep one segment of society out of the (judicial) branch of government.

"Sen. Buttars is using his religious views to run a blatantly unconstitutional bill; it's wrong," she said.

More than 80 percent of the 104 members of the Utah Legislature are members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, which has actively opposed proposed same-sex legislation and citizen initiatives in other states.

No one is expecting religious institutions to accept gay marriages, said Michael Mitchell, executive director of Unity Utah, a gay and lesbian political action committee. "The idea of a religious marriage is not impacted by what we're talking about. We're talking about the civil institution of marriage that is bestowed by the government, a government that gay and lesbian couples pay taxes to."

Biskupski also said Buttars' proposal is unnecessary because Utah already has a law saying two people of the same sex cannot be married.

State law says any union between two people of the same sex is void in Utah, said associate legislative general counsel Esther Chelsea-McCarty, who is drafting Buttars' bill.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Image
Charles Krupa, Associated Press

Gay partners Gina Smith and Heidi Norton, left, and Gloria Bailey and Linda Davies celebrate in Boston after Massachusetts' top court ruled that gay couples are legally entitled to wed. The four women were among plaintiffs.

previousnext

Latest comments

Utes remain silent about BCS

BSU: 1 BCS > 0 BCS from BYU Hawaii: 1 BCS > 0 BCS from BYU and... Mighty...

SLC council OKs gay rights policies

since you posted about 20 comments in a row, it really doesn't matter if some...

Prejean is a horrible example as she was FIRED FOR NOT DOING HER JOB! She...

woulda coulda shoulda - just more of the same pg fan talking smack because...

A serious illness can try the souls of all involved. People can make a...

My wife has MS and we have battled together with it. In sickness and in...

I love the false claim that Jon Huntsman is a "self-made man"! Ha! What a...

SLC council OKs gay rights policies

["are we defining "marriage" so narrowly that all it means to us is the...

Editorial: Mormons and gay rights

RE: Re: Pagan | 5:47 p.m. Nov. 12, 2009 You honestly believe that...

yoot fans have nothing better to do, especially since there are self-serve...

Advertisements
Advertisement