David R. Nemelka's three-year battle with federal prosecutors ended with his acquittal this summer on all 30 charges against him. But the Mapleton businessman says he's feeling no joy or desire to celebrate.
He has, however, emerged from his legal battle with a greater respect for America and the justice system."No, we are not bitter. We are thankful. In other countries I may have just disappeared or been shot," Nemelka wrote recently in a letter to friends and the media.
In January 1993, a Colorado grand jury indicted Nemelka and three others on 18 counts of mail fraud and 12 counts of money laundering. The indictment alleged that the four schemed to defraud clients of Powers Securities Corp., a company specializing in the sale of penny stocks.
The indictment accused Nemelka of paying more than $2 million in kickbacks to Richard T. Marchese and Orville L. Sandberg to sell the securities he controlled. In addition, it alleged that Nemelka and Marchese set up companies to conceal the payments. A federal judge dismissed the charges in 1994, ruling there were no victims because prosecutors failed to prove anyone lost money.
The charges were reinstated, however, when the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the government only had to show money was obtained through false representations.
But following a lengthy trial in Denver, U.S. District Judge Lewis T. Babcock ruled in April that Nemelka and the other defendants were not guilty of all charges. He said prosecutors never proved the defendants concocted a scheme to defraud.
However, the judge did say that Nemelka probably paid money under the table to Marchese to market stocks he controlled but that the government must show more than a defendant is probably guilty.
"Because in our system guilt must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and the more-probable-than-not standard isn't that standard," Babcock said.
The judge went further than finding Nemelka not guilty. He called many of the government's witnesses liars, many of whom are former associates of Nemelka who accepted plea bargains. He also chastised prosecutors for filing charges on allegations that don't even violate securities laws.
"If one complies with the securities laws as highly regulated as they are, that should be sufficient to satisfy the broader goals of the mail fraud statute," the judge said.
Now that he's been found not guilty a second time, Nemelka said he's emotionally relieved and optimistic that his family's best years lie ahead.
- Deseret News Exclusive: Excerpt from Clayton Christensen's 'How Will You Measure Your Life?'
- Women married to NFL Mormons do best to keep things normal at home
- Teen's dad spends school year waving at bus, embarrassing son
- Deseret News Exclusive: Mormon prep basketball phenom Jabari Parker makes the cover of Sports Illustrated
- KSL TV news icon Bruce Lindsay calls it a career
- Claim jumping accusations fly in the new West
- Billboard battle heats up as company files...
- Is this dress too short? Tooele teen gets...
- Romney's veepstakes: Buzz builds around Rob...
- 10 memorable stories covered by Bruce Lindsay
- 6 arrested after police say they tortured...
- Custody battle over dead woman's children...
- Stay-at-home mothers find challenge,...
40 - Stained-glass ceiling: Study says...
34 - Orrin Hatch is now the hunted —...
27 - Sen. Mike Lee forced to sell...
26 - Billboard battle heats up as company...
26 - Matheson, Love engage in lively...
21 - Liljenquist TV ad aims to pressure...
20 - How will Palin endorsement affect Hatch...
19






DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
— About comments