From Deseret News archives:

Defects, distrust left in wake of military testing

Published: Monday, Feb. 12, 2001 10:11 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Of all the poisonous residue the federal government left throughout Utah because of its secret military tests, perhaps the most toxic is distrust of the government.

In the early 1950s, Gilbert Dean Hill worked for a contractor, painting bunker doorways, water barrels and other objects at Dugway Proving Ground, 80 miles west of Salt Lake City.

Hill would stay at Dugway from Monday through Friday and go home for the weekend. One day around 1952, when he was returning to the barracks after work, a supervisor asked, "Why were you guys out in the field today? Don't you know you weren't supposed to be out there?"

No, said Hill, "Nobody told us."

The supervisor said that some testing was going on. Then he added, "but it's OK, because it's nothing that could hurt you."

What the World War II veteran did not know in 1952 — what almost nobody in Utah knew until a few years ago — is that in addition to extensive open-air nerve gas, bacteriological warfare and simulant experiments, Dugway carried out at least 74 secret tests to scatter radioactive material in the atmosphere. Many of the tests were in the late 1940s and early 1950s.

Total radiation released was 153,000 curies, or 10,000 times the level released by the near-meltdown at Three Mile Island.

Story continues below
All the Hill family knew is that birth defects showed up in a child born after the incident (since deceased), and that Gilbert Hill died of an agonizing illness that destroyed nerves in his lungs.

"When we moved him in here, his right nerve was totally dead and his left nerve was partially, which meant that he could not lean back or lie down in his bed or he would suffocate," said his son, Nolan Hill of Kearns.

For the past 10 or 11 years of Gilbert Hill's life, he never slept in bed. "He would either sit in a chair and lean on a table, or he would kneel down by an ottoman chair in his room and lean on it."

When Gilbert Hill died in 1997, the obituary in the Deseret News began, "Returned to his loving Father's arms after years of physical suffering caused by exposure to the secret Dugway radiation test in 1952."

During a trial seeking compensation for the cancer deaths of southern Utah residents, former Atomic Energy Commission fallout monitor Frank Butrico testified he was stationed in St. George on May 19, 1953, for a nuclear test that has come to be called "Dirty Harry."

Fallout began hitting St. George at 8:30 a.m. Then, between 9:15 and 9:30 a.m., Butrico's instrument was off the dial, indicating exposure greater than 300 milliroentgens per hour.

Recent comments

As a survivor as torture at the hands of the United States...

ruhullaha | April 30, 2009 at 1:19 p.m.

THIS IS ALL VERY SAD ,TO THINK OUR GONERNMENT WOULD DO THIS AND THEN...

FR | Jan. 27, 2009 at 6:35 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Hall's legacy measured today

gotta love how Utah fans keep dragging last year's accomplishments into this...

Efforts to save a life praised

I apologize to the family for this clinical comment and don't mean to sound...

What doe the Book of Mormon have to do with Christianity?

Hall's legacy measured today

You can rag on Max Hall all day but at the end of the day he has accomplished...

Been there, he'll be washed up by the time he returns. I am sure he will...

Boys basketball rankings

I know Haws is doing well. How is Wilcox doing at Washington?

Editorial: Who wants ethics reform?

We all know Democrats would use any guise to get power. Why don't they solve...

Much unknown about warming

"To plot temperatures going back hundreds or thousands of years – long...

I agree with Scott 100%. Please don't close the whole cave...

Highland players make special friend

and wonderfully simple. These young men did not set out to do anything...

Advertisements