Two years ago, financial planners arriving for their annual convention in Chicago found a shiny red Corvette glittering in the middle of the exhibition floor.
The car was a prize offered to the planner who did the most business for a certain investment company.This year the meeting was in New York, and there was a car again. But it was a back-to-basics black 1946 Continental, and it was part of the decor. Nobody was giving it away.
Gone along with the prize Corvette were most of the real-estate tax-shelter marketers who brought big promotions and big commissions to financial planning.
Indeed, a year after the stock market crash and two years after tax reform, this is an industry in transition.
After years of selling tax shelters and high-commission mutual funds to the well-to-do, planners are having to find another way to make a living. Some are having a hard time doing it.
"The people who have really been hurt by tax reform and by the market crash tend to be people who were focused on product sales," said Larry Carroll, chairman of the International Association for Financial Planning, the industry's largest trade group and sponsor of the meeting here. "They tend to have moved on to other things."
Carroll estimated that the average planner's income is down 10 to 25 percent from a year or two ago. The IAFP's own membership has declined 12 to 15 percent from its peak 21/2 years ago, and attendance at the convention was down proportionally from the high-water mark of 5,500 in Chicago.
Change was even more visible on the convention floor. The number of exhibitors declined from 575 last year in Atlanta to 475 here, with most of the drop coming among the real-estate syndicators. The falloff would have been even more dramatic but for 100 new entrants, led by insurance companies, appearing for the first time.
"The mix of people that are on our exhibit floor is typically a very good representation of the revenue mix or the investment mix of the average planner," Carroll said. "And you'll find the average planner is doing very little in the real-estate area at this point."
The departure of the high-risk, high-commission products and the resulting economic pressure on planners is producing another effect - the rediscovery of the middle class.
Traditionally, planners have focused on high-income clients, because most financial planning had its genesis in tax planning. It continued because the wealthy were best able to pay the fees of fee-based planners, or to make the investments that generated the commissions to support the commission-based planner.
But along with the recent tax-reform and stock-market problems, there has been a growing realization among planners that there aren't enough rich people to go around.
So the industry is being forced into what Atlanta planner Gail L. Cook calls "financial planning for the yachtless."
"For planners to survive, we really are going to have to pay attention to this market," she said. "They represent the broadest segment of the market available to us," and in many cases "they are the affluent of tomorrow."
Marketing to this group is refocusing attention on the question of payment.
Most planners get at least some of their income from commissions. They recommend certain investments to clients and get money when the client buys in.
Other planners who work for fees alone, along with some outside observers, question the objectivity of advice given by someone with a financial interest.
And still other critics argue that commission-based planners are likely to lose interest in the client once the sale is made.
- Parents of eight children both have cancer,...
- Officer who killed family had dark side,...
- Man honored for saving 3-year-old from...
- Utah to appeal same-sex marriage ruling to...
- Body of 14-year-old American Fork boy...
- BYU students took cover in bomb shelter...
- Teen admits starting 5-alarm Baron Woolen...
- 'Wicked' returns to Salt Lake City for 2...
- Group protests Hobby Lobby decision on... 60
- Utah to appeal same-sex marriage ruling... 45
- Rep. Chaffetz keeps Romney for... 38
- Same-sex marriage advocates to deliver... 37
- What's next for immigration reform? 27
- 83% of Utahns say Congress needs to act... 27
- Officer who killed family had dark... 24
- Jehovah's Witnesses spread Bible message 21