New Patrick Henry Caucus already drafting bills for 2010

Published: Friday, June 19, 2009 10:54 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 

The newly formed Patrick Henry Caucus in the Utah Legislature won't just call press conferences and complain.

Instead, it is pushing an agenda that will flex the state's muscle on issues such as gun control and environmental policy in ways it hopes will elevate the fight to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Additionally, since the formation of the caucus last month, members have been reaching out to like-minded lawmakers in other states to pass similar laws, a tactical move they hope will only bolster their planned judicial battle.

Already, the caucus members are drafting bills to run in the 2010 session.

Rep. Carl Wimmer, R-Herriman, says he is working on a bill that aims to tell local and state law officers that they can't enforce any federal law unless there is a corresponding state law. In other words, the FBI, Secret Service, ATF and other federal law enforcement agencies would, alone, be responsible for enforcing federal laws here.

While that would prevent the federal government from enforcing its more restrictive gun laws in the state, it could also prevent local police from enforcing federal immigration laws.

Story continues below

"It is tricky," admits Wimmer about the possible conflict with immigration statutes. "I don't want to harm SB81 in any way. We fully support SB81."

SB81 is a broad immigration reform law set to take effect July 1, and a voluntary aspect of the bill allows local police agencies to cross-deputize their officers to enforce federal immigration laws. So far, most agencies have declined to cross-deputize.

He said it's too early to give many examples of where local police and county sheriffs would be stopped from helping federal law officers. However, Wimmer, a former local police officer, said one place could be some joint task forces where federal, state and local police run combined criminal investigations.

Reps. Ken Sumsion, R-Lehi, and Christopher Herrod, R-Provo, are looking at other areas, such as federal regulations enforced by the Environmental Protection Agency.

Holding a strict interpretation of the U.S. Constitution's commerce clause (which provides for federal authority in regulating inter-state trade), they suggest that, for example, those federal laws would not be enforceable if a Utah coal mine sold its coal to a Utah power plant, which then burned the coal for Utah customers only and sequestered the carbon in Utah soil.

"The EPA could have no jurisdiction," Herrod said. The construction and emissions of such a plant would have to meet only state regulations, he said.

Sumsion said there could be many instances were federal regulations or law could be basically kept out of the state if there is really no impact across Utah borders.

Recent comments

The Patrick Henry Caucus looks like a great tool for American...

liberty4all | Aug. 25, 2009 at 10:54 p.m.

The 17th amendment should be kept at is. Most of the Patrick Henry...

17th | June 22, 2009 at 5:33 p.m.

I never realized that the 17th Amendment (providing for the election...

uncannygunman | June 20, 2009 at 2:18 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Health care bill clears Senate hurdle

We will look back at this day (well, our kids will) and say "that is the day...

Hall breaks BYU record with win

Weren't you saying Air Force would win today??? Where are you now? It's so...

Glenn Beck to enter politics?

Glenn Beck has more substantive content, thoughtful perspective, pure...

Glenn Beck to enter politics?

the Liberals just can't take it when we are "Right" about someone Perhaps...

Be very careful what you wish for. Have any of you read the bill? It is a...

Harry Reid saved the taxpayer $150 million. He was willing to offer and...

If the Deseret News did the kind of fact checking when doing its local...

For RSL, being late worked

For Americans this Sunday will be full of family time, American football, and...

I agree with you Keith. Beck's popularity is increasing because people want...

Did the girls from region 16 just not get picked or they not able to play in...

Advertisements