Israel finds itself at crossroads in Gaza invasion

Published: Monday, Jan. 12, 2009 2:23 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
JERUSALEM — Israel is fast approaching the moment when it needs to decide between escalating its Gaza offensive, putting its soldiers at greater risk, or quieting its guns perhaps without achieving its top aim of ending Hamas' weapons smuggling across the Gaza-Egypt border.

Hamas, too, is at a crossroads. A quick cease-fire would spare Gaza further devastation. But it could also keep the militants from reaching their key objective of opening Gaza's borders.

Israeli officials on Monday were weighing whether to take their 17-day offensive to a new, more violent phase — invading Gaza's heavily populated areas to try to go after Hamas leaders and weapons stores and pressure the group to enter a truce on Israel's terms. This could be very costly in terms of human life on both sides and yield uncertain results.

A second option is to halt the offensive as part of a truce deal that gives Hamas what it wants: an end to the blockade of Gaza imposed after the militants violently overran the coastal territory 18 months ago. While this would stop the war, it would also likely cement Hamas' hold on power in Gaza — an unwelcome outcome for Israel.

Story continues below

Israel could simply declare victory and get out, content with the deterrent effect that's already been achieved. Hamas would almost certainly think twice before firing rockets on Israel again. This option, unless accompanied by an internationally backed arrangement for the Gaza-Egypt border, could leave Hamas free to keep smuggling in the weapons that threaten hundreds of thousands of Israelis.

Under another scenario, Israel could also declare victory and remain in key parts of Gaza, effectively reoccupying territory it left in 2005's withdrawal.

International mediators expressed hope Monday that a cease-fire could be achieved. Tony Blair, the former British prime minister who now serves as an international Mideast envoy, said in Cairo that the "elements of an agreement ... are there" and that he hoped to see a truce "in the coming days."

Hossam Zaki, spokesman for the Egyptian foreign ministry, told the BBC that cease-fire talks in Cairo were "progressing." He suggested the sides might agree to stop fighting even while details of a truce deal were being worked out.

However, when asked about what is probably the main requirement for any truce to work — guaranteeing Israel that Hamas' rockets and arms smuggling will stop — he said, "Egypt is not in the business of giving guarantees of such a nature."

Despite the truce talk, Israel appears to be in no great hurry to halt its fire. The fighting has killed 870 Palestinians, but only 13 Israelis. Israel believes it has the upper hand, and may see a military escalation as an opportunity to pin Hamas to the wall, maintaining the Gaza blockade while at the same time safeguarding the border with Egypt.

Recent comments

I think Israel should pull back with the warning that if the Hamas...

2 bits | Jan. 12, 2009 at 5:09 p.m.

Image
Associated Press

Israeli reservists are seen before crossing for a combat mission into Gaza, near Israel's border with Gaza, in southern Israel, Monday.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

I love this country deeply and what it's freedoms have meant to my particular...

contributions above about the oddness of this article. I realize that a...

I have heard over and over that a 16 or 8 team playoff would "ruin" college...

there is this new bakugan (wantu) that is on TV, but it has not even been...

Beck making most of rare time off job

Whose level are you referring to, Helen? Your BYU fans are capable of...

@Vshar, let's hope your right that the end to your greed, selfishness, and...

Thank God that there were then and now are men like this police officer. And...

Well, you're the one who made the claim that "Obama is a snake that is...

If you took an immunology class at school, you would know that the flu taken...

I could care less about the luxury tax situation. All of it is mute if we...

Advertisements