From Deseret News archives:

BCS system isn't fair — so what?

Published: Saturday, Jan. 10, 2009 9:43 p.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Maybe you had the same reaction I did when Mark Shurtleff, who happens to be the attorney general of the state of Utah, said he was considering suing the Bowl Championship Series because the University of Utah football team wasn't crowned national champion.

Uh-oh.

Lawyers!

Shurtleff's contention is that the BCS is "patently unfair" because it favors certain schools and leagues over others. And of course he is right. The BCS is elitist, money-driven and favors the strong and the talented.

And since when was that news?

And since when were sports fair?

You learn that pretty much the first time someone — someone tall, like Shurtleff — blocks your jump shot. Or when the wind switches from a headwind to a tailwind at precisely the same moment the other guy hits his tee shot.

You go, "Hey, that isn't fair."

Few things in sports are, starting with DNA, moving on to where you live and how much money you have and going from there.

That's not to say there aren't honest attempts at leveling the playing field, as it were. Wrestling, for an example, tries to be fair by establishing weight classes, and boxing, too, although in boxing there are so many competing organizations that at any given time there are as many boxers wearing championship belts as there are ways to get knocked out.

Story continues below
You think they argue about who's No. 1 in college football? In boxing it's an eternal filibuster.

Not having a college football playoff is unfair, no doubt about it. (And please put me down — again — in favor of a playoff.) But having a playoff isn't totally fair, either. Just ask the 66th-ranked team when the national basketball tournament limits its national tournament to 65.

If the attorney general is serious about challenging inequities in college football through lawsuits, he might want to start by enjoining a system that rewards 18-, 19- and 20-year-old young men with a Blu-ray player for playing in the Sugar Bowl while their coaches get hundred-thousand-dollar bonuses and the schools they play for divvy up millions.

Or backing up a step further, he might want to look into representing football players who are forced to attend algebra and English classes as a prerequisite to playing on the team. Maybe they don't care for algebra and English, other than tospeak it. I mean, how fair is that?

But it's sports. It's not something to go to war over — or to court. One of the great things about fun and games is that in the end that's what it is — fun and games.

Recent comments

If Utah Had A Stronger Shecudle They Wouldnt Hav Gone Undfeated I...

Landon | Dec. 3, 2009 at 10:39 a.m.

I may not be a fan of any Utah team, but after watching the game...

Isaiah | Jan. 27, 2009 at 3:09 p.m.

Sounds like the man who wrote this is bitter the Utes went 13-0 and...

Kelli | Jan. 14, 2009 at 9:00 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

MWC race shaping 'Survivor' style

Huh? Where'd those ideas come from?

Obviously genius, you have no idea what you are talking about. The jury has a...

1:43 p.m., you realize that under the Defense of Marriage Act or DOMA that a...

Stake formed in Uganda

The idea Christianity has never taken route in India is not supportable by...

Lawmakers, educators debate plan

Those of you that want to keep attacking teachers you will reap what you sow....

@To Kevin, Anon, Pagan | 11:43 a.m. Feb. 9, 2010 I'm arguing repealing...

To: SoCalPat, You do a lot of ranting about BYU, but don't have a lot of...

U.'s Texas trio expects support

I wouldn't trade BYU's history of success for two fluke years. Call me...

Europe searches for solution to debt

Brian | 1:17 p.m. Of course NO BLAME should be handed to Obama. You guys...

Didn't West Jordan beat the mighty region four champs last year? I don't...

Advertisements