Shurtleff considers probe of the BCS

He calls it an 'unfair system,' looks to build antitrust case

Published: Tuesday, Jan. 6, 2009 1:33 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff was among the fans at the Sugar Bowl, cheering wildly as the Utes defeated the Alabama Crimson Tide.

Now, fuming over their apparent denial of a national championship after an undefeated season, he's considering launching an investigation into college football's Bowl Championship Series. Shurtleff plans to meet with some of his lawyers and investigators next week to consider building an antitrust case against the BCS.

"This game proved that it's an unfair system," the attorney general said in an interview with the Deseret News on Monday. "A team like Utah will never be given a chance."

BCS administrator Bill Hancock said it would be inappropriate to comment on something organization officials have yet to see. "I would say the system we have for postseason football is the one that was agreed upon by all 11 conferences," he said.

To make an antitrust case, Shurtleff has to argue a conspiracy that, in effect, creates a monopoly. In the BCS system, he suggested that with thousands of athletes and millions of dollars at stake, the BCS schools get more money, better stadiums and better recruits. Add to it the ranking and voting system for which teams get into a BCS bowl game, it removes schools like Utah.

Story continues below
"How do you substitute greed and money for heart and guts?" Shurtleff said.

The BCS is made up of the various college football conferences and the University of Notre Dame. Any legal action taken against the BCS may have to include all of those schools.

"Under the BCS, the access for all 119 teams is greater than it was before," Hancock said Monday.

The University of Oklahoma Sooners (12-1) and University of Florida Gators (12-1) play for the BCS championship on Thursday in Miami.

Shurtleff raised questions about BCS antitrust practices when Utah went to the Fiesta Bowl in 2004 but dropped it when Congress began looking into it.

"The BCS said, 'Let us fix it,"' he said.

Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, held hearings on the BCS in 2003 as chairman of the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee, accusing the entity of bias against non-BCS teams. Following the U.'s Sugar Bowl win last week, Hatch repeated his criticisms.

"Regardless of what happens in the Florida-Oklahoma game, the outcome will not change the fact that there is only one undefeated team in Division I college football: the University of Utah," Hatch said. "For the second time in four years, the BCS-busting Utes have gone undefeated and yet uninvited to play for a national championship. That needs to change because the system is broken. The BCS is fatally flawed and, until it is fixed, will continue to produce a flawed college football champion."

Recent comments


As for all you whiners talking about this a waste of money and the...

Anonymous | March 11, 2009 at 3:27 p.m.

Hey Bama fan!

"Only the MWC!?!?!"

That's exactly the kind of...

HugeUtesFan | March 11, 2009 at 3:26 p.m.

I give a hats off to Utah, I am an Alabama fan, but the Utes beat us...

William | Jan. 8, 2009 at 7:36 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Letters: Hatred goes 2 ways

"everyone has a story" including Max Hall!

Romney did save the Olympics in 2002 so perhaps he could save our country.

If want to see a coach that operates at the top of what every Dad wants in a...

Past Mr. Football winners

Tate went to USU first and they stayed behind him with his fight against...

Pitta named to All-America team

RE: Let’s be honest. I have to agree that a 5th round pick seems about...

Couldn't the same thing be said for those who are signing a petition in...

Many members of the church seem to claim much more faith than they really...

Group "E" or Group "A"

It is a federal budgetry item, so yes you do pay. Second response to Anoy...

Death penalty possible in slayings

America: Country of Drug Addicts. Legal or illegal, WE Americans need our...

Advertisements