Utah Utes football: Flawless U. exposes flawed BCS bowl system

Published: Saturday, Jan. 3, 2009 12:23 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
A perfect season should yield a bigger reward.

College football has a real credibility problem.

Thanks to the University of Utah's dominating win over Alabama in Friday's Sugar Bowl, the NCAA's failure to take control of its football championship — yielding to a money mercenary called the BCS — was again exposed.

Short of calling the BCS a fraud, it is a significantly flawed system of determining a college football champion.

It is patently unfair and goes against the spirit of competition that rules in every other NCAA sport.

For the third time in five years a non-BCS school (Utah in 2004 and 2008 and Boise State in 2006) ended its season unbeaten, untied and uninvited to play for a national championship. Utah is 2-0 in BCS games, and the 2004 team, in my opinion, was superior to the one that whipped Alabama.

While the Utes and Broncos were included in a BCS bowl game and triumphed, a system created to keep them out of the title picture did just that and only adds to the controversy and debate of the controversial system.

The BCS, created to stage a championship, places a lot of weight in favor of teams from the six BCS conferences in the title game selection. Using human polls and two computer rankings that place a big emphasis on strength of schedule and margin of victory, we will get No. 1 Florida playing No. 2 Oklahoma on Thursday night for the title.

Story continues below

Trouble is both Florida and Oklahoma lost games this season.

Florida lost to an unranked Mississippi on its home field. Oklahoma lost to then-ranked No. 5 Texas by 10 points.

Utah, ranked No. 6, finished the season 13-0 with victories over four ranked teams, including Friday's win over Alabama, a squad ranked No. 1 for five weeks.

Should Utah have received more serious consideration for an appearance in a championship game? Should Boise State, undefeated in 2006 and victorious over Oklahoma in the Fiesta Bowl, have received the same opportunity?

If the answer is no, then perhaps the championship in this sport should be determined after a series of playoff games have run their course. Sounds only fair for teams that never lost a game.

Utah's victim, the Crimson Tide, held the No. 1 spot longer than any other college team this season. Southern Cal was ranked No. 1 for four weeks before losing to Oregon State.

And that brings us to whom Utah defeated in Rice-Eccles Stadium back in September — Oregon State.

This leaves only Utah and Florida to have defeated Alabama, a team the BCS system determined was the best team in the country for the longest period of time, a team coached by the national coach of the year, Nick Saban, shown regularly on TV melting down.

Recent comments

Some people are really going out of their way and making the kind of...

FERN | May 14, 2009 at 1:24 p.m.

hope this lawsuit works and not only sues the BCS but ends this...

Anonymous | Jan. 8, 2009 at 4:29 p.m.

Well, Alabama is the one crying, now.

cindy | Jan. 7, 2009 at 6:54 p.m.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

No climate crisis

science is not determined by a majority. If it were then we would be in an...

Price was on the team the entire year. What did he do to earn a new...

If it's an area where buses idle for a long time there should be hookups...

The Jazz are crazy if they offer Millsap anything over 5 million a year. He...

Thanks Mark B. for your input. Where was anyone seven years ago? If I'm not...

Ut. County is mainly Republican, so what if that's how they want to celebrate...

they can just sit and wait and play mind games with Utah. They have cap...

NO matter how good of a player you are, if you do not fit in sloans...

A Couple points, first, as a Ute fan, Ludwig drove me nuts, I could call the...

Palin did the right thing. She didn't make her family suffer any more for the...

Advertisements
Advertisement