From Deseret News archives:

'Boston' attacks Utah

Published: Monday, Nov. 3, 2008 12:28 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Gee, David E. Kelley must have Googled polygamy. And, in the hands of the executive producer/writer of "Boston Legal," a little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

In another over-the-top episode of the soon-to-be-gone ABC series, Kelley climbed back up on his soapbox last week. And made himself look like a pompous, uninformed bully.

Yes, it's fiction. But it's fascinating how the same folks who would never descend to racial stereotyping have no problem with geographic or religious stereotyping.

Kelley and co-writer Corinne Brinkerhoff sent the comedy team of Alan Shore (James Spader) and Denny Crane (William Shatner) to a dude ranch in Utah — because, of course, all of Utah is a rural dude ranch. And the plot descended into sexual idiocy and infidelity involving Denny.

At which point he is arrested because "adultery is a crime in Utah, as is fornication out of wedlock."

Something Kelley and Co. apparently ran across on the Internet. But they missed the part about those laws not being enforced.

This being a Hollywood depiction of Utah, the stereotypes started flying thick and fast. Like when Alan called for the case to be moved to "any jurisdiction where the criminal justice code isn't written in the Good Book."

Story continues below
Of course, Utah means one thing only to Kelley and his ilk — polygamy.

"Utah is not the state that wants to prosecute adultery," Alan, charged as an accomplice, told the judge. "While it may technically be a crime, so is polygamy, which you don't prosecute.

"Your own attorney general went on record saying you lack the resources to go after all the polygamists," Alan continued. "And let's face it, you've got a lot of them. Not a judgment. Personally, I'm a fan. So's Denny.... I even find polygamy funny, just a little. These loser guys with all these women, the hairdos."

So polygamy is awful and awfully funny.

But if the show didn't falsely portray that Utah enforces fornication laws, then Alan wouldn't have been able to threaten to use the case to expose Utah's failure to enforce anti-polygamy laws. And, in one of the few things Kelley got right, he had Alan point out that "in many cases there's child abuse involved."

"I'm ready to take on the state ... and you and everyone you're married to," Alan told the judge.

I'm sure Kelley felt he was balancing things by having the judge say, "Polygamy is illegal in Utah and not practiced by the majority."

But attorney Melvin Palmer (Christopher Rich) shot back, "But it goes, Judge. It goes on. And, like he said, often with underage girls."

Recent comments

come on now, aren't we past the point where we take this stuff...

Tai | Nov. 16, 2008 at 1:30 p.m.

This is concerning Polygamy and "Bill" who made the comment that a...

Enlightened | Nov. 11, 2008 at 12:53 a.m.

Is it.. John Packer Lambert or John Pack Lambert or John Pack Lambort...

i'm Confused??? | Nov. 7, 2008 at 8:36 a.m.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

strike the "violence" against marriage comment Otterson. This is uncalled...

House passes health care bill

You are so wrong, "Eye in the News", the quote of James Madison shows that...

As well-intentioned as this stance by the church is, it nevertheless...

Navajo Code Talkers break silence

Thank you for your service, and I look forward to visiting the new Code...

4A preview: Springville vs. Dixie

Do you honestly believe Dixie is the best in the State? You obviously have...

Mendenhall should prepare their team like Utah by using purple jerseys in...

Wyoming writer amazed by BYU

That's a ridiculous thought that any team or player would lose on purpose. ...

Party insiders may take on Bennett

Fred Lampropoulos is a great businessman and should stay here running things....

Maybe the LDS church fears the backlash of the movie 8 the Mormon...

There is also no such thing as "the Ukraine". And that is great advice to...

Advertisements
Advertisement