From Deseret News archives:

Utah approach to health reform is way too slow

Published: Sunday, Oct. 26, 2008 12:08 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
My wife and I have started a new round of wrangling with our health insurance provider.

This happens about once a year. They won't pay for a child's regular visit to the doctor because they say the doctor's office failed to fill out a form properly. The doctor's office complies, and then the insurance company once again balks for some technical reason. And each time, we deal with a different representative on the phone.

My wife turned to me last week and said, "Can you imagine how difficult this would be if the government ran health care."

Yes, indeed. As inefficient as our private insurer is at times, it does operate under a profit incentive. A government agency with all the incentive of the DMV would have to be worse.

And yet there has to be something better than both systems. My biggest worry is we won't find out.

Story continues below
The Utah Legislature has begun implementing what it calls a 1-3-6-10 plan to health-care reform. Those aren't lucky bingo numbers. They aren't a new Dr. Pepper ad campaign for when you should want more. Those are years. It will take one year to establish a foundation for reform by convening a task force, three years to come up with a plan that addresses six areas of reform and, finally, about 10 years to put everything in place.

By that time, two more presidential elections will have passed, as will five legislative elections. The health-care-reform train will have left the station.

On one level, it makes sense to work deliberately and carefully to solve a complicated problem. But on a more realistic level, two men are running for the White House right now with grand plans for health-care reform that could make whatever the state does irrelevant. Each candidate has outlined these on his Web site. Significantly, John McCain's is the only one that mentions giving states the flexibility to experiment. But, of course, 535 members of Congress will want to put their own fingerprints on whatever becomes law.

When that happens, 1-3-6-10 may better describe the number of years you would have to wait for different types of medical procedures.

Utah has no shortage of experts ready to provide a road map for market-driven change. The Salt Lake Chamber has a bill of rights for health-care reform. This plan includes making sure workers, not their employers, are the ones making decisions, and that the system is completely transparent. Patients should know how much a procedure will cost, and they should know the success rates of doctors, hospitals and other facilities that perform those procedures.

Recent comments

I don't think Jay is thinking clearly when he says government...

The Dude | Oct. 27, 2008 at 9:15 a.m.

See the George Will piece today on Arizona's proposed amndment to...

John | Oct. 26, 2008 at 8:54 p.m.

@Dave Hansen.

I disagree with you about a single-payer system....

Anyonous | Oct. 26, 2008 at 1:05 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Congrats on the first win! finish out last place please so we get the #1...

Y. scientists rip lawmakers on climate

Re: Kevin in the Terrace | 10:46am You want me to "...Try the peer...

Utes pound winless Lobos

is everyone forgetting Utah beat New Mexico.....New Mexico has not won a...

Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings

My mistake. My memory failed. In 1995 the Jazz did finish 60-22 and 27-14...

2A: Broncos stampede South Sevier

between south summit and san juan have been great like in 98 south summit was...

Utah is the most overrated of the Top 25 teams. I find it laughable when Ute...

Get out of debt, stay out of debt, avoid it like it was a democrat.

...to understand the slow start. Remember this is their rebuilding year...

Bennett's anti-Obama TV ad

Senator Bennett for standing up against making the next chapter in American...

Visit to paradise nightmarish for Ags

Always easy to kick a program when they are down. By the way, did you know...

Advertisements
Advertisement