From Deseret News archives:

Utah doctors say industry must share blame

They say health system rewards quantity over quality of results

Published: Sunday, Sept. 7, 2008 12:19 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Departing from the usual "It's not our fault" assessment of why the cost of U.S. health care is hemorrhaging, a group of Utah physicians attending an annual roundtable discussion Saturday cited their own practices as a contributing factor.

Presenters at the University of Utah School of Medicine's 10th annual alumni conference weren't asked to specifically address the whys and wherefores of the skyrocketing cost of medical care. By the end of the five-hour session, however, the meeting had shifted into a kind of solutions triage.

Just as quality of care equates to a "spare-no-expense" attitude among U.S. health-care consumers, health-care providers have operated under a type of spare-no-procedure approach, several speakers and attendees said during a question-and-answer period that concluded the day.

Some of the doctors labeled the health-care delivery system as "perverse" because it is built to reward quantity of procedures over quality of outcomes. The doctors' acceptance that they are contributing to the problems is not an official stance within the state medical society, nor is it a mea culpa by the doctors.

Story continues below
But Dr. Brent James, the chief quality officer and executive director of the Institute for Health Care Delivery Research at Intermountain Healthcare in Salt Lake, said that just showing a willingness to examine their own house in light of the crisis is a signal that maybe the crisis will bring an end to the finger-pointing mode within the system that has caused previous, equally sincere reform efforts to run aground.

"In an era when we routinely achieve miracles in medicine, we have a striking inability to do what we know works," James said, noting that in every sector, there are huge amounts of waste and spiraling prices that limit access to care for consumers and limit front-line care providers' ultimate goal of producing the best result possible for each patient.

Quoting Francis Bacon, a fellow expert who wrestled with innovation in the 16th century, James said: "He that will not apply new remedies must expect new evils; for time is the greatest innovator."

The evil of the current U.S. health-care system could be summed up in the numerous studies that show the United States system is by far the most expensive, while it is near the bottom in quality and beneficial outcome measurements compared with 19 other first-world countries.

"We've got a lot of questions to answer and situations to answer for," said Linn Baker, who implemented the statewide preferred-provider network for public employees. He is chairman of the Utah Health Policy Project's governing board.

Recent comments

I hate to interrupt the scare tactics, lies, and indiscriminate...

Medical Malpractice Myth | Sept. 8, 2008 at 2:24 p.m.

There have been some great comments posted about this article. When...

Everyone | Sept. 8, 2008 at 12:18 p.m.

There are two major problems:

1 Legal - our doctors wouldn't have...

SLC gal | Sept. 8, 2008 at 11:26 a.m.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

Thank you for your service, Steve Butler.

Gay advocates trek to LDS office

"Which was the same argument made when a black man wanted to marry a white...

The thing is it was an article about gorbachev and not ronnie because...

in my opinion, they should leave it off, and take of the remaining portion as...

Oh my goodness, Don--a bit of hyperbole, no? Are you satisfied to continue...

Sacrifices of soldiers not forgotten

Beautiful essay, Ann. My father-in-law came in on Utah Beach 24 hours after...

Prep girls soccer MVPs named

C'mon D-News

Thats right raise the tax on the poor.

2 arrested in $3 robbery

Wow. Seriously? Who pissed in your orange juice this morning? Two men...

Kay McIff says big families don't really need a tax break? I thought this...

Advertisements
Advertisement