From Deseret News archives:

Wilco plays musical modern art

Published: Wednesday, Aug. 20, 2008 12:14 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
WILCO AND FLEET FOXES, Red Butte Garden, Monday

Watching Wilco perform live is like visiting the great Catalan city on the eastern coast of Spain: eclectic, modern, creative. Especially creative.

In fact, the creative energy seems to crash like tidal waves from the stage, just as it overwhelms a visitor to Barcelona. It is a mysterious, yet unmistakable, rush of energy.

From the opening sounds of "Remember the Mountain Bed" to the closing rim shots of "Kingpin," Wilco proved repeatedly why it is the greatest American rock band of this century and one of the greatest of any era. It fills an amplifier like Picasso covered a canvas.

Too much? Bombastic? Over the top? Picasso — seriously?

Seriously. The band is that good, and any doubts otherwise were laid to rest Monday night at Red Butte Garden.

There has never been any question about Jeff Tweedy's talent as a musician and a lyricist, since the Uncle Tupelo days. He is the Joan Brossa of modern American music.

Story continues below
However, he is complemented by some of the finest musicians playing today, most notably, Nels Cline. On many songs — especially "Via Chicago" and "Poor Places" on Monday night — Cline shaped feedback into masterpiece, the same way Dali shaped crooked geometry into poetry.

On drums, Glenn Kotche is the Antoni Gaudi of the band, with his ability to elevate the role of "Heavy Metal Drummer" into something akin to a deity. The normally straight lines of a rock drummer are warped by Kotche, who often seems to have sprouted a third, or even a fourth, arm during his playing.

What Wilco creates on stage is as much modern art as it is music. Because of that, it is challenging, but the audience is growing, and the fans, a passionate bunch, appreciate the strokes of genius.

On Monday night, practically every song in the band's set — which included 21 songs, two encores and lasted well over two hours — could be called a masterpiece. But the best of a remarkably strong set were "Via Chicago," the always classic "Jesus, Etc.," "Spiders (Kidsmoke)" and the all-out jam "I'm the Man Who Loves You."

As an added bonus, Tweedy was also very funny, poking fun at the freeloaders sitting on the hill above the amphitheater ("Somebody will be up there with a hat, collecting money"), the name of the venue, and rock 'n' roll pretensions such as the call-and-response or encores.

The Seattle-based Fleet Foxes, which specializes in delicate harmonies and soaring melodies, played a short but extremely strong set to open. The talent of Fleet Foxes, in fact, only served to emphasize how well Wilco really played.

Wilco's greatness, in the wider context, will remain a subject of debate. But Monday night's show was easily one of the best ever played in Red Butte, if not anywhere.


E-mail: jloftin@desnews.com

Recent comments

So what is your definition of Art Music then? John Cage? Philip...

Huh? | Aug. 20, 2008 at 5:06 p.m.

Do you? You chide the critic for being unable to distinguish between...

Tweedy gets postmodernism | Aug. 20, 2008 at 4:28 p.m.

Wilco proved why they are at the upper echelon of musicians on that...

Great Show | Aug. 20, 2008 at 4:13 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Is it me, or did this article take a 180 degree directional sporting change...

Lambert says he got carried away

Another evidence of style over substance. His lack of talent is shining...

We have been overdoing it for a really long time. We need to think about...

It seems that every time someone gets trapped in that cave there is a...

BYU's old uniforms?

BYU's current uniform color is actually closer to the team's original color...

Obama to pledge 17% cut in CO2

Too bad he didn't pledge to cut methane gas in half by the year 2012, the...

Matt Reynolds vs. Koa Misi

The only thing that matters is emotion. Throw the game plan out the window...

This is so awfully sad. My heart goes out to his entire family and friends.

BYU's old uniforms?

At least BYU has tradition to look back upon, unlike the utes. Let's see your...

Thunder rolls by Jazz

will look a lot better in April than it does now. OKC is a second round...

Advertisements