Electoral College or popular vote best?

Published: Sunday, Aug. 17, 2008 12:39 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Webb: One of the truly sad, even disastrous, characteristics of the modern U.S. political system is that states, once proud and sovereign, have been relegated to insignificant status, literally bit players in the federal system. The relentless encroachment by the federal government via constitutional amendments, court cases, congressional action and regulatory fiat has concentrated money and control at the national level.

The result is a federal government paralyzed by problems and issues so large it can't handle them. But break those problems down state-by-state, and they become manageable. Give Utah's state and local governments most of the federal tax dollars we generate, plus the authority to act, and we will deal with Medicaid, Medicare, Social Security, health care, transportation, the environment and so forth. Let the federal government handle those few, limited responsibilities intended by the Founders, and let the states do the rest.

Those determined to abolish the Electoral College are really advocating further emasculation of the states, leading to more concentration of power at the federal level. The Electoral College is one of the few remaining tools the states have to ensure that presidential candidates pay attention to them.

Story continues below

The Electoral College's winner-take-all system forces candidates to conduct state-by-state campaigns, to pay special attention to "battleground states." Candidates have to respect states. Sitting presidents eyeing re-election listen to governors and state leaders because they need those states' electoral votes.

Under a popular vote system, state boundaries and individual state priorities would become irrelevant, getting no attention except for a little lip service. Rather than deploy state-by-state strategies, where states matter and have a voice, candidates would ignore states and instead target national demographic segments in the gigantic population centers like New York City and Los Angeles. It would dramatically change the dynamics of presidential campaigns.

Joseph J. Ellis, professor of history at Mount Holyoke College, said the Founders instituted the Electoral College so that major decisions like electing a president would "pass through succeeding layers of deliberation. They established not a democracy, but a republic, in which popular opinion had to battle its way through artfully contrived chambers of refinement before reaching the promised land of political power."

If we eliminate the last vestiges of state clout and authority, we might as well eliminate states and just have one vast federal government where everything is decided in Washington. States are being stomped on and ignored. States need a few tools, like the Electoral College, to have any chance to compete in the federal system.

Recent comments

Perhaps the Hitler thing wasn't the best analogy but with plurality...

Re: Debunking | Aug. 18, 2008 at 2:13 p.m.

Raymond,

I read your post with great interest. Your solution...

Mike Richards | Aug. 18, 2008 at 12:04 p.m.

Hitler and his Nazi Party would have come to power in Germany earlier...

Debunking Hitler myth | Aug. 18, 2008 at 11:28 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Didn't Obama and Biden just admit to the fact that the stimilus programs were...

The last part of the article about Cowherd is classic!!! I normally like the...

This man was my teacher in high school. He is my friend, he was like a father...

I like millsap, but portland just burried themselves. They made themselves...

It's amazing how quickly society is willing to vaccinate it's children with...

The first income tax was introduced during the Civil War, that's only 70...

If he really did what the evidence seems to show, I don't think he should be...

Utah needs Portland too much. It's much harder than you think to find good...

Restaurant destroyed by fire

stacy, have you ever eaten there ??

I had Brother Pratt at Viewmont High School my sophomore year... I was really...

Advertisements