From Deseret News archives:

BYU football: Ranking is just a good start

Published: Saturday, Aug. 2, 2008 12:05 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
So, the Cougars are ranked in a preseason poll for the first time in 11 years? What does it really mean?

In simplistic terms, it means nothing.

Then it gets more complicated.

If your program hasn't been ranked in any beginners' poll for a dozen years, it speaks to respect. Then you have to go out and earn it.

Remember in 1984 Pitt was ranked No. 3, then lost to BYU and went in the toilet.

On the other hand, if you don't get some momentum in polls these days, you'll be paddling up the river most of the season, even if you run the table.

It's not fair. It isn't the way it is supposed to be. But that's college football circa 2008.

These days, with complicated computer formulas, polls, rankings and votes determining the finish in the lucrative BCS poll, getting ranked in any way, shape or form is imperative. It's like earning one of the preferred spots during a preliminary heat of a race.

There are good lanes and bad lanes.

The coach's poll, published by USA Today, has the Cougars No. 17. Between BYU and the coveted Top 10 loom No. 10 Texas, No. 11 Auburn, then Wisconsin, Kansas, Texas Tech, Virginia Tech and Arizona State.

Story continues below
If BYU does its part and wins, there's a tough gauntlet to maneuver every week to chip away at those in front of them. But starting at No. 17 is a better spot than Hawaii began its campaign a year ago at No. 24. The Warriors climbed to No. 22 on Sept. 2 before running the table to stand No. 10 in week 14 before the bowls.

Bronco Mendenhall puts little stock in preseason polls or rankings during the season because he knows it doesn't provide a real value, with one exception. He knows if you want to get where Utah, Boise State and Hawaii did in a BCS bowl, it is a major advantage to be ranked before the season starts than to chip your way in from nowhere.

Other than that, it's puffery and opinions, and one is as valuable as another. Back 11 years ago when the Cougars were last ranked in August, they finished a disappointing 6-5, fifth in the WAC's Mountain Division.

Thud.

Mendenhall recognizes this could happen to his team, just like it did to that of LaVell Edwards. Youth and success, he says, is a dangerous combination in sports; if you get complacent or cocky, you could fall.

Mendenhall told reporters in Las Vegas back in July his team could be set up for a "perfect storm," and that his approach with players like QB Max Hall, TE Dennis Pitta, receiver Austin Collie and D-lineman Jan Jorgensen is to warn them they're just beginning.

Recent comments

So. Cal Fan--You were probably too young to remember, but in 1984 BYU...

Be real | Aug. 3, 2008 at 11:44 a.m.

Preseason rankings mean a whole lot more than nothing. They are...

Big B | Aug. 2, 2008 at 10:28 p.m.

Get real. This is a time that lost to Tulsa not so long ago. Did that...

Get real | Aug. 2, 2008 at 9:58 p.m.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

Prep boys basketball top 20

Deseret News, would you please post the boys' basketball all-state 2008-09...

I hope the judge and the grand jury do what the public has been demanding for...

If the PC politicians don't want to fight wars to win, then lets just get the...

Tiger withdraws from tourney

Why not just leave Tiger and his wife alone?? After all, it's their lives...

Even the comments on this board are utterly absurd. I'm LDS and am totally...

Hall reprimanded by MWC

Stop the hate. Go Utes!!!

tcu beat a dang good clemson team at clemson...and they beat byu at byu...and...

Political correctness strikes again. Hall was correct...maybe he should not...

"Why not talk to police?" Are they kidding? No one should ever talk to police...

I don't see that much "Tradition, Spirit, Honor." (from the BYU football...

Advertisements