USIA needs to be revived to fight anti-Americanism

Published: Wednesday, July 23, 2008 12:11 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Each candidate in the presidential election has recognized the need, once in office, to galvanize public diplomacy to improve the image of the United States abroad.

Congress is also seized of the issue. A House subcommittee has held a series of hearings that affirm in recent years a "precipitous decline in favorability" toward the United States and its foreign policy.

At the urging of Congress, the Department of State, current home of the government's public diplomacy efforts, has commissioned a study to review the instruments and techniques needed to burnish the U.S. image. Three interested organizations, the Brookings Institution, the Business for Diplomatic Action group and the Washington-based Public Diplomacy Council, will conduct hearings in Washington, New York and Los Angeles in July to assess the views of interested parties.

Key to the debate is whether the government's public diplomacy, or "soft-power" effort, should remain based in the State Department or should become a separate institution. Republican candidate John McCain has already pronounced on his choice if he becomes president. In Foreign Affairs, he wrote: "In 1998 the Clinton administration and Congress mistakenly agreed to abolish the U.S. Information Agency and move its public diplomacy functions to the State Department. This amounted to unilateral disarmament in the war of ideas. I will work with Congress to create a new independent agency with the sole purpose of getting America's message to the world — a critical element in combating Islamic extremism and restoring the positive image of our country abroad."

Story continues below

With the end of the Cold War, adopting the happy view that America's foes were now few, Congress opted to make public diplomacy a lower priority. USIA programs were cut back, and the remnants and lingering personnel of the agency eventually subsumed under the State Department, whose professional diplomats are schooled not in public relations, but the art of close-to-the-chest, government-to-government negotiations. Public diplomacy has thus been deprived of a separate agency whose sole reason for being is to amplify the American story to publics around the world, using the latest communications technology and the skills of practitioners who live, breathe and dream the mission.

While the Bush administration has admirably championed democracy around the globe, it has not restored the infrastructure to engage doubters and those whose anti-U.S. prejudices defy reason. When Karen Hughes, President Bush's media guru, was appointed the State Department's undersecretary for public diplomacy, many supporters of public diplomacy hoped her political heft could persuade the president to do what must be done — restore or replicate USIA. But within the confines of the department, she was only able to shift chairs around on a deck, rather than launch a new ship.

Recent comments

For all the Mormons in the house, there was a political adviser from...

IIE Again... | Aug. 21, 2008 at 3:38 p.m.

Working for the International Visitor Leadership Program under the...

IIE | Aug. 21, 2008 at 3:26 p.m.

Wow. Thomas sees so many stupid people out there. That means he must...

Lewt | July 23, 2008 at 9:26 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Stadium of Fire flag burning was fake

Just consider who they chose as the guest MC: Glenn Beck from "Fox News",...

It was pageantry. I assume you've all been to Manti. When you watch a...

Sacred = Deceit? This statement sums it up: "We felt, in the spirit and...

Every time I am in down town Salt Lake I see that idiot building just sitting...

i like okur. and he is a model citizen for the jazz. if boozer goes, okur...

Obama controls all

To "Rise up? | 7:30 a.m." so you say "We rid ourselves of the 8 year cancer...

I love it. Couldn't agree more.

What a bunch of moronic posts! Science is supposed to be about skeptism,...

I like today's story about Biden that said: According to the White House...

I am glad (sarcastically) how the Obama administration will back up a petty...

Advertisements