From Deseret News archives:

Primary election postmortem

Published: Thursday, June 26, 2008 12:02 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
If you voted Tuesday, you can skip this diatribe and go back to eating your Cheerios.

The rest of you, read on. By virtue of sitting out this election, you allowed less than 10 percent of the state's registered voters to select the Republican candidates for one congressional seat, state treasurer and some state legislative races. After all the furor over the split of the Jordan School District, a paltry number of voters turned out for those races, too.

What gives?

Sure, it's summer, and many of you have your minds on other things. And yes, some of you may be confused — or troubled — by the closed primary election process used by Utah's Republican Party. Seemingly, requiring people to affiliate as Republicans to participate in the Republican primary scares off or offends a certain number of you. While party operatives contend that requiring people to register heads off attempts by Democrats and others to manipulate elections, more harm is done by excluding people from voting. The conservative 3rd Congressional District hasn't elected a Democrat since Bill Orton, whose third term ended in January 1997. That means the Republican primary is, in effect, the general election for residents of the 3rd District.

Story continues below
For those of you who just didn't bother to vote, shame on you. For those who refused to vote because you were required to affiliate as a Republican, shame on the Utah GOP for establishing a requirement that discourages participation in primary elections. Under the best of circumstances it is difficult to get Utahns interested in politics during the summer. This rule creates another hurdle.

Six-term 3rd District Rep. Chris Cannon was ousted by challenger Jason Chaffetz in Tuesday's election, a loss Cannon attributed to low voter turnout and Americans' frustration with high gas prices and other issues. Cannon may also have been upended by his position on immigration, which has been more moderate than that of many residents of his congressional district.

Interestingly, one of the more strident anti-immigration voices in the Utah Legislature, GOP incumbent Glenn Donnelson, was handily defeated in an interparty challenge by Ryan Wilcox. Wilcox, however, said his victory had more to do with "shoe leather" and the help of volunteers. Chaffetz also attributes his victory to a hard-working grass-roots organization.

Absent exit polling, it is difficult to pinpoint why — on a certain day in June — one candidate defeats another. The larger concern is the dwindling number of voters taking part in primary elections since the races were moved to June from September. Between that shift and closed primaries, too few Utahns are participating in elections to select their leaders. That's a regrettable trend.

Recent comments

We had ONE person early vote, she was one of the other Poll Workers...

RE:re:Anonymous | June 27, 2008 at 5:00 p.m.

*** "If the Republicans want to hold a closed primary, why DO I HAVE...

Wilkey | June 26, 2008 at 9:36 p.m.

I registered Republican so I could vote AGAINST Cannon and Walker....

Thanks Republicans | June 26, 2008 at 3:37 p.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

i know south sevier is returning a lot of players but who do waterford and...

blake. you made a difference today in someones life. 20 years later I don't...

Girls basketball rankings

Go region 16; Rebels, Eagles, Longhorns!!!!!!!!!

@ Christy | 7:03 p.m. Dec. 1, 2009 What can my family do for a soldier for...

I heard all the sirens, and actually drove through there not five minutes...

BYU says Hall incident resolved

I am a big BYU fan and will support them always, but as far as Max Hall and...

Prep boys basketball top 20

How are they not as loaded as they were in football? 6 of the 7 teams are...

Philpot may run for Congress

Go For It Nancy Pelosi will remain Speaker of House which is an...

Hall violated the BYU honor code, and in doing so he brings dishonor to...

BYU says Hall incident resolved

The UGLY side of sports came to light Saturday, namely Utah's fans despicable...

Advertisements