From Deseret News archives:
'Nudity tax' challenged
Sexually oriented businesses say statute is unconstitutional
Adult businesses that feature nude or semi-nude dancers and escort services challenged the constitutionality of a "gross receipts tax" on their services before the Utah Supreme Court, saying that the tax infringes on their rights to free speech and expression under the First Amendment.
In oral arguments presented Tuesday, the Utah State Tax Commission disagreed, arguing that the statute is targeted toward the "negative secondary effects" of the content presented in these establishments, and like alcohol or tobacco taxes, this too is a constitutional response from the Legislature.
Title 59 of Utah Code levies a content-based gross income tax of 10 percent on sexually explicit businesses and escort services.
The statute was passed in the 2004 legislative session and enacted on July 1 of that year. Certain portions of the funds raised are earmarked for the investigation and treatment of sex offenders.
Justice Jill Parish asked McCullough if the state were able to produce empirical evidence that showed a connection between patrons' attendance at sexually oriented businesses and sex offenses in the area if the tax would then be justified.
McCullough said that the state was not able to produce that evidence.
While questioning the content neutrality of the statute, the court asked if the tax would be applied to theater or dance companies that feature segments of full-frontal nudity in productions such as "Oh! Calcutta!" or the musical "Hair."
The commission's attorney, Nancy Kemp, responded by saying the tax would apply to any businesses that featured semi-nude or nude performances beyond 30 calender days.
When Chief Justice Christine Durham further pressed the commission on the breadth of the statute and its application to constitutionally protected speech like "Oh! Calcutta!," the commission said that to date no instances have arisen where a fine arts establishment have met the criteria required for taxation. In the event that the show did go beyond a 30-day run, the tax would apply to them as well.
Chief Justice Durham said that because the statute is being contested on its face value and could be applied to "well-known" theatrical productions, the court will be required to closely examine the language in the statute. The court will issue a ruling at a later date.
E-mail: cnorten@desnews.com
Recent comments
In my experience when the Supreme Court delays in making a decision...
Falconer | Oct. 15, 2008 at 12:06 p.m.
About four years ago, the late, great Reagan adviser Lyn Nofziger...
Sarah, several cities are wrong | June 8, 2008 at 12:45 a.m.
MANY cities in the US have an "entertainment" tax for things like...
Sarah | June 6, 2008 at 7:06 a.m.
- 3A: Hurricane 24, Park City 19 2:29 a.m.
- GameDay back in the MWC 2:19 a.m.
- Westminster campus briefs 1:49 a.m.
- SUU campus briefs 1:48 a.m.
- Dixie campus briefs 1:47 a.m.
- Real Salt Lake gameday 1:33 a.m.
- 5A: Bingham rolls to title game 12:59 a.m.
- Aggies hope for Spartan cure 12:57 a.m.
- 5A: Miners pull tricks to win 12:56 a.m.
- 5A: Davis runs over Hunter 12:54 a.m.
- Williams leaves, won't play tonight
- Unga family is making its mark
- Selfishness to blame for Jazz woes?
- Study: Divorce likely when wife ill
- ESPN suddenly loves MWC
- Trial begins in toddler death
- Historically, Utes have owned TCU
- Man killed during 3rd I-15 crash
- Two killed in Iron County crash
- 4A: Thunderbirds dynasty lives on
- SLC council OKs gay rights policies
348 - Editorial: Mormons and gay rights
199 - Senators want food tax restored
162 - Will state consider gay rights law?
145 - Letters: Strange breed in Utah
129 - Utes remain silent about BCS
120 - S.L. vote pending on gay protections
113 - Celtics crush Jazz
103 - Pratt pleads not guilty to sex charges
102 - Hatch empathizes with Muslims
88
If you are looking for a bird on the cheap, the following specials from...
How do you handle kids and contests? Our oldest daughter, 7, is of the...
True. It's not terribly funny and if it has any effect on society, it won't...
What else would you expect to find in a book called "The Founders on Religion"?
Ok not to be rude here, but check the stats, Hinds isnt first in yards and...
t-hinds = best player in utah
Anonymous: Was that English? I though conservatives believed if you are in...
Wow! Glad the Lord kept you safe. Separate comment: That was a horrible...
I have never been to a Utah high school game before as I am not from the...
It would behoove the above commenters to recall that religion, including our...
Only 8000 attendance? BYU had 16,000+ tonight. What is wrong with Ute fans?...
ian you are the 3A MVP If you win next week so just do it that would be nice....
