From Deseret News archives:

Will signing abuse papers come back to haunt FLDS?

Published: Sunday, May 25, 2008 12:12 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
SAN ANGELO, Texas — Desperate to be reunited with their children, many Texas FLDS parents signed family service plans that concede child abuse and neglect.

It's an admission that may come back to haunt them if criminal charges are ever filed accusing them of being abusive parents.

With Thursday's appellate ruling, the civil case against the families appears to be unraveling, but the criminal probe continues. Results from DNA testing on the parents and children are anticipated in the next week and could potentially link adult men to children of underage girls.

That is why several attorneys this past week appearing in status hearings in the Tom Green County Courthouse advised their clients to refuse to sign.

Both Stephanie Goodman and Gonzalo Rios were adamant that the FLDS parents they represent steer clear of the family service plans drafted by the state Department of Family and Protective Services.

"It could be construed in a criminal case that it is an admission that those are the things that happened on the ranch," Goodman said.

The plans crafted for the more than 450 children taken into custody by the agency in April include several mandates the families were to have followed in order to get their children back.

Story continues below
All the plans were identical and included the requirement that parents get counseling as it relates to child abuse and child sexual abuse.

That requirement, Rios said, immediately concedes child abuse and sexual abuse took place — a concession that would jeopardize a parent's rights in criminal court.

"You can't sign a document in one case that admits abuse and go to court on another case and say that you're innocent, that these things didn't happen. You can't have it both ways."

To the chagrin of state attorneys representing the child welfare agency and to the annoyance of the judge, Rios in hearings on Monday would not even let his client, Barbara Steed Jessop, verbally acknowledge that she had read the document. He told Judge Barbara Walther — the same judge who approved taking the children in early April — that his client had read and understood the plan, and he answered on her behalf.

"There's a criminal investigation that is ongoing, and my client is not in any way, shape or form agreeing with allegations contained in the plan," Rios told the judge.

The service plans in child welfare cases are like a contract between the parents and the agency, Goodman and Rios explained, and the parents they represent would have been legally bound to follow all their requirements.

Recent comments

Have you ever heard of the 5th amendment? Sure doesn't sound like it.

yo desnews | May 26, 2008 at 8:06 p.m.

As a general rule ALL citizens should be wary of signing any document...

Deaf Ears | May 26, 2008 at 1:21 a.m.

I'm not a Mormon, and don't live in Utah, so I didn't know until...

Thankful for Fair Press in SLC | May 25, 2008 at 11:45 p.m.

Image
Brian Connelly, Associated Press

FLDS members wait outside the courthouse after Thursday's verdict. The ruling has been appealed.

previousnext

Latest comments

I was at the city council vote. I spoke before them and gave them my example...

There are a few out there who are "traditional" country. If you have a...

Animal rights group sues Morgan Co.

Let's consult the Constitution on this one: "Congress shall make no law...

I agree with one aspect of your rational, we are strange and "fair minded"....

I am a Ute fan, I am glad Whitt chose the U over you, however, I have to give...

Utes remain silent about BCS

in ewe clothing "Utah has about a 30% chance against TCU" 1:100 is 1%,...

The Utes are rather arrogant about the success they have once every 4 years....

I believe the worst place in the world to learn about Sex ed is in a...

Letters: Companies sold out

Our prosperity was built on cheap and widely available fuel. That's the...

Letters: Obama 'too busy'

Mr Obama has time to do what he considers important. Things like...

Advertisements
Advertisement