From Deseret News archives:

Coal and Mother Earth: Proposed coal plant pits economy against Navajo beliefs

Published: Wednesday, May 21, 2008 1:06 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
"It's all about politics. We've met all of the requirements, done all of the work, and yet we're still waiting," said Christopher Deschene, an attorney for the Dine Power Authority, the tribe's partner in the project. "This is our back yard. We can handle this."

The EPA says it was initially delayed by climate-modeling uncertainties for a region that includes several national parks, and then by nearly 1,000 mostly negative comments posted on the agency's Web site. Air-permit technicians say they have a duty to answer each of the comments.

Added to the debate is a recent analysis of government temperature data that shows the interior American West is heating up at twice the global rate.

"We think we're doing our job as best we can — the good technical work that we are required to do," said Colleen McKaughan, a Southwest region deputy air-division director for the EPA. She declined to provide a timeline for action.

Environmental groups have vowed to keep fighting any EPA permit.

"There is no such thing as clean coal," said Theodore Spencer, a climate policy analyst for the Natural Resources Defense Council. "Coal power is pretty much the dirtiest power there is, and that plant would do nothing to address global-warming emissions."

Recent comments

Think of it this way, God gave mankind the coal. If we refuse his...

Don't be ungrateful | May 21, 2008 at 10:57 p.m.

Big "liberal" cities outsourcing their pollution to indian...

mad monk | May 21, 2008 at 6:37 p.m.

Ban coal and nuclear. Solar, wind, and water are unavailable or too...

Anonymous | May 21, 2008 at 1:35 p.m.

Image
Paul Foy, Associated Press

The Four Corners plant routinely ranks No. 1 on dirty-power lists compiled by watchdog groups.

previousnext

Latest comments

Please provide your level of education, history of experience and any other...

Its so much better to consider that these professionals are working in jobs...

Huckabee lie? Can you say those two words in the same sentence?

Congrats to all the Kanab Cowboys! Especially Rhees and Stets for first...

Clear road map? Maybe to the cliff's edge!

Here's a thought: maybe if we "paid as we slayed" (thanks, uncannygunman), we...

I've got to say that this matchup looks like one of the best bowl matchups...

BYU professor remembered

I was so impressed on meeting Dale Le Baron at the first CES meeting in Cape...

Utes excited to go to San Diego

Cal is a name, and a decent team from a very good conference. Best case...

FYI most high school students have taken Algebra 1 in junior high. I am a...

Advertisements