From Deseret News archives:

Advocacy group: Sex abuse would trump FLDS religious freedoms

Published: Thursday, May 8, 2008 12:33 p.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
A legal advocacy group has filed a brief in the FLDS case, warning the Texas 3rd Court of Appeals against making "hasty judgments" that could violate parental rights and trample religious freedoms.

The friend of the court brief was filed by the Liberty Legal Institute, which describes itself as an organization committed to the defense of religious freedoms and First Amendment rights in Texas.

But the brief argues that should Texas provide proof that sexual abuse of minors occurred at the YFZ Ranch, that legally trumps religious freedoms protections and parental rights.

Attorneys for Texas RioGrande Legal Aid filed an appeal last month asking the appeals court to reverse 51st District Judge Barbara Walther's decision to have all 464 children removed from the church's YFZ Ranch. The appeal was filed by 38 women from the Fundamentalist LDS Church who are seeking to have more than 400 children returned to their mothers.

The children were placed into state custody after Texas authorities discovered what they called a dangerous pattern of abuse at the ranch, including a culture of underage girls marrying much older men.

Story continues below
The Liberty Legal Institute did not file in support of either Texas RioGrande Legal Aid or the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services. While concerned about parental rights, the institute argued that if Texas has proof of sexual abuse at the ranch, that proof would take legal precedence over parental rights.

"This is not about choosing a side, it's about protecting the foundational freedoms of parents and churches in the midst of a very pressured situation for the courts," said Hiram Sasser, director of litigation at the institute.

The brief reminds the appellatecourt that any state action that infringes on parental rights is subject to strict scrutiny. However, "if there is evidence ... the state has shown that the health, safety or welfare of the children is imminently threatened or in danger, such a finding is enough to meet the state's burden under strict scrutiny," the brief states.

In fact, if sexual exploitation is proven, the institute argues that no additional analysis of parental rights would be necessary and would actually "damage the rights of all parents in Texas by lowering the standard of protection" given to parental rights.

"The key for this court is to follow the proper procedure and protect the rights of all parents in the process. Otherwise, every Texan loses their freedoms and the standard of protection is lowered for everyone," said Kelly Shackelford, chief counsel for Liberty Legal Institute. The group makes a similar argument about constitutional religious protections.

Recent comments

Re: Re: I -no | 9:10 a.m. May 9, 2008

Many are screaming for...

evidence | May 9, 2008 at 9:56 a.m.

The �better conditions� you describe.... have you left out the...

Re John & others | May 9, 2008 at 9:42 a.m.

"OBSERVER" must be one of the FLDS lawyer...because this person seems...

Funny | May 9, 2008 at 9:13 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Letters: Chosen behavior?

Religious freedom is a "special protection" enshrined in the U.S....

Letters: Trash or truth?

But there's one major flaw in your thinking. Since ALL of Beck's,...

Celtics crush Jazz

Why quote Boozer when he is a huge part of the problem. The problem will not...

What a great segment. I enjoy reading this very much. Thanks!!

Beck, Hannity, and Limbaugh get the audience they deserve and vice versa. ...

I find the rule,very discriminitory. I am not gay, I don't understand what...

Celtics crush Jazz

I understand we were outmanned last night. However, this effort was awful....

Tavernari has matured

My advice to Jonathan is shoot it when they pass it to you as soon as you...

Maybe they should try drafting a shooting guard who can shoot from outside ....

The sad thing about it is that there are actually people out there that are...

Advertisements
Advertisement