From Deseret News archives:

School board selection may get less murky

Published: Saturday, April 19, 2008 12:49 a.m. MDT
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Our son Matt turns 18 this September, in time to vote for president of the United States.

Heady stuff, right?

Matt didn't even have to wait that long to cast his first vote. State rules wisely allow 17-year-olds who will be 18 before a November general election to participate eight months early at neighborhood caucuses in the spring and again in the primary election in the summer.

That gives them a say in which candidates will appear on their ballot in November.

Naturally, Matt was eager to tag along with us to our neighborhood's Republican caucus last month. But then something like first-time voter's remorse set in.

His mom joined in selecting delegates who will represent our area at the party's state and county conventions. For different reasons, Matt and I sat it out. I needed to remain an impartial observer. Matt felt overwhelmed by issues he'd never considered deeply, like school vouchers and immigration.

Thousands of Utahns will make a similar choice this November. People who rarely turn out to vote will show up en masse to vote in the presidential race but then opt out of voting in the state school board race.

Their reason will be Matt's: Who knows anything about the state school board?

Story continues below
But with school vouchers immediately behind us and Round 2 probably somewhere ahead of us in the future, the state school board election is more important than ever, no matter which side you're on.

Some observers are concerned that it is possible to stack the school board to lean one way.

Here's how: In 2002, the Legislature created a committee to whittle down the number of school board candidates. The committee interviews them and selects three per seat to recommend to the governor.

The governor then selects two to go on the ballot.

The committee will do some serious whittling this year, because 37 people filed for seven seats. In District 13, seven Provoans filed for a single seat.

So what if the committee stacks the list it gives the governor with one type of candidate? The Legislature tried to guard against that by balancing the committee with six people from business and industry and six from education.

But if one person crosses over to vote with the other group in a bloc, it's possible the governor could get a list of three people who are all pro-business and pro-voucher. Or vice versa. Voters would be presented with little choice.

Recent comments

Maybe, Margaret Dayton will say that the governor has a "property...

What is next? | April 21, 2008 at 1:55 a.m.

Tad, one additional point of information to your story, this...

BBking | April 19, 2008 at 7:54 a.m.

Another rigged election? Shouldn't the school districts choose their...

Bob G | April 19, 2008 at 5:54 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

Not this year buddy. TCU will own the Utes.

Thurl Bailey's wonderful life

Thurl i just saw you in person lol you went to my brothers school, Riverview...

Cougars land Vegas standout

Actually, ASU offered Collinsworth and wanted him very badly. So the score is...

It would be interesting to know how religiosity modifies the results if at...

GO TIMPVIEW 38-21!! I Guess trash talk only gets you so far..

Even the TDS fans can appreciate this. I think a mountain west team has been...

House passes health care bill

Got me there :) Dr shortage in Japan. They still have the option of opening...

Should districts pay union reps?

The concept is too crazy to deserve comment.

Utes remain silent about BCS

Over-rated. The fact that the y was ever rated in the top 20 this or last...

4A: Springville holds off Dixie

Any coach can tell you that there is something to be said about having your...

Advertisements
Advertisement