Chinese firms hard to sue

U.S. competitors face myriad legal hurdles

Published: Saturday, Feb. 9, 2008 12:12 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
NEWARK, N.J. — When an American scootermaker lost patience with cheaper Chinese-made models flooding the United States market, it got some attention by filing an antitrust lawsuit.

Patmont Motor Werks Inc. accused the Chinese government and companies there of making it impossible for the company, based in Minden, Nev., to sell its products to Chinese. One aim of the lawsuit was to open China's doors to American-made products.

That improbable goal is now in ashes, when Patmont's lawyers couldn't even track down the companies they were suing to serve them court papers.

An increasing number of companies and individuals are likely to face similar frustration. The flood of Chinese imports has triggered a growing number of lawsuits, but individuals and companies often find it impossible to win damages or other legal redress, especially for lawsuits filed overseas. Foreign companies are also filing lawsuits in Chinese courts, and occasionally winning, against local companies caught violating trademarks, copyrights and patents.

The legal obstacles are unlikely to be removed soon, although China has pledged to curb its mounting trade surpluses with the United States and has carried out a nationwide campaign to improve product quality and safety.

Story continues below

Within a decade, however, China is likely to conform more closely to international legal standards, said Gary Hufbauer, a China expert at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, a Washington think tank.

"The drift is clearly toward a normalized situation," he said.

Current obstacles arise because the targets of lawsuits are often companies that are partly owned by the Chinese government or army, or are allied with provincial governors, said Hufbauer. As a result, their clout can outweigh efforts by the trade ministry to adhere to international agreements, he said.

In addition, he said the Chinese government sometimes obstructs litigation to retaliate when it believes the United States or the European Union is "poking it with a stick."

Washington's growing impatience over Chinese trade practices has prompted dozens of retaliatory bills in Congress, as the U.S. trade deficit with China for 2007 is expected to exceed a record $250 billion. The U.S. lawmakers view 2008 — when China hosts the Olympics — as an opportunity to highlight their grievances.

Experts in international law say they know of no case in which Americans collected any money from a verdict or court order against a Chinese company, although some have been paid through settlements.

A federal judge dismissed the Patmont lawsuit 2 1/2 years after it was filed because Patmont had been unable to deliver the lawsuit to the defendants, as court rules require.

Recent comments

At some point the items get delivered to the U.S. and payment is made...

l | Feb. 9, 2008 at 7:14 p.m.

If we really felt any sympathy for domesitc firms, we'd buy from...

my two cents | Feb. 9, 2008 at 12:14 p.m.

Sounds like a laywer would have a tough time making a living in China...

Dave | Feb. 9, 2008 at 8:05 a.m.

Image

Steve McElvain works on a push scooter at Patmont Motor Werks in Minden, Nev. The scooter company filed an antitrust lawsuit over Chinese trade practices in an effort to level the playing field for American companies asserting claims of product piracy, impure ingredients and unsafe products.

previousnext

Latest comments

The contract offered to Milsap is similar to the original one the Jazz gave...

Millard County van rollover kills boy, injures 7

ate carol/kuya rey....We are really sad of what happened...but one thing for...

Hate to break it to ya, Blauch, but every time Memo leaves the floor Boozer...

The Gospel of Jesus Christ has no room for these silly myths. This is the...

paul is a good player but i say see ya get rid of loozer and ak i would...

My family is devastated! We know the Pratts personally and have loved their...

I think all of us grew up hearing these myths. I'm glad Mckay Copins had the...

This makes me so sad! He was a great teacher, it was the only time i ever...

Good job Brother Coppins. Thanks for being a source of moderation and...

at a Martial Art finals in Oklahoma City one year and thoroughly enjoyed the...

Advertisements