From Deseret News archives:

'His Illegal Self' just doesn't work

Published: Sunday, Jan. 27, 2008 12:31 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
HIS ILLEGAL SELF, by Peter Carey, Knopf, 275 pages, $24.95.

Best known for "The True History of the Kelly Gang," Booker Prize-winning Australian novelist Peter Carey seems to have an affinity for outlaws. His new book, his 13th, "His Illegal Self," carries that theme as he tells the story of Che, often mispronounced Jay, and Dial, a pretty young woman who represents the hippie generation of the late '60s and early '70s.

Failing to realize she is being used by others, Dial, as she calls herself, steals Che, an 8-year-old boy, from his Grandma Selkirk, who thinks she is borrowing him for one hour. Instead, the eccentrically dressed woman takes him out of New York and flies him to Australia without ever telling the boy or the grandmother what she is doing.

Che doesn't object to the kidnapping because he thinks the young woman is his real mother, whom he has never met — and he likes her, even though she is quite awkward much of the time. A bit strange for someone who is a faculty member of English at Vassar College. She wins him over by reading to him for several hours.

Story continues below
Che has been hoping his real parents, who were radical student activists at Harvard, would show up one day to take him home. But he is surprised and puzzled when he lands in a hippie commune in the jungle of tropical Queensland. He keeps wondering when his real father will appear.

Meanwhile, Dial leads the boy from one dangerous place to another, hooking up with two drugged and scary men who threaten them, drive them to various weird places and steal their money.

The book is written as if it were seen through the eyes of the 8-year-old, with short, incomplete, ambiguous sentences that often leave the reader wondering what he/she is missing. The vocabulary often seems pulled out of the air but is only occasionally obscene.

Billed by the publisher as "the best fictional work to explore the militant radical underground of the late 1960s and early '70s," it is instead a misguided, failed attempt to either comprehend or explain that period. Some readers are apt to keep reading simply because of curiosity, but continued reading will not satisfy.

The novel just doesn't work.

The characters remain enigmatic and unlikable, except for the boy, from beginning to end. Lots of names of real people alleged to be hippies in the '60s are used, but that is the extent of the historical basis. As for Australia, the author knows the lay of the land. Not enough in this case.


E-mail: dennis@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

previousnext

Latest comments

Jazz win 6th in 7 games

First off I have been a Boozer supporter all along. Boozer is top 3-5PF....

No fractures on Emery's foot

JT also needs someone to watch to help him understand the meaning of terms...

Some people have claimed that it was Whit's son who took the cell phone and...

Utes won't respond to Hall

Mendenhall and Whittingham should stand up and take a stand on this one. A...

I guess Utah fans have some planning to do for next year's Utah-BYU game.

Religion in politics is tiresome

@ S. Reno, Are you saying that abortion is not a religious issue? When...

I don't remember any Utes chasing George. The only Utes in the picture...

2 citations issued at Y.-U. game

MY experience is just the opposite. I have been insulted and mistreated in...

Nutty Putty Cave will close

Adult thinking: The man who died in the nutty putty cave deserves respect...

BYU says Hall incident resolved

Mendenhall and Whittingham need to take a stand and cool this thing down....

Advertisements