From Deseret News archives:

Don't take early baskets too seriously

Published: Sunday, Jan. 13, 2008 12:08 a.m. MST
 |  E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Imagine you're watching a basketball game when one team scores a two-point shot early in the first quarter, then runs off the court and holds a press conference. Amid whoops and hollers, the coaches announce how grateful they are for this early victory and urge their supporters to stick with them.

You'd think someone had slipped something into the Gatorade.

And yet, in effect, that's how the presidential campaign season is being presented to us, with one addition. To make the analogy complete, the coaches would be hoping the early basket would help them raise the money necessary to keep the players going until the end of the game.

Early last week, commentators were describing Barack Obama's campaign as surging in energy following the win in Iowa. People were openly making comparisons to Robert Kennedy in 1968 and even whispering about concerns for Obama's safety. Then came the reality of New Hampshire, and suddenly Obama looks more like Eugene McCarthy. Mitt Romney, meanwhile, is described as desperately in need of a win, and John McCain, while maybe not a kid, has been said to have made a comeback.

In reality, one source has Romney leading the overall Republican delegate count, while Hillary Clinton has a sizeable lead on Obama. But other sources have it differently. Delegates are like water, fluid.

In short, we really don't know anything yet.

Story continues below
I understand the need for campaign momentum, which depends a lot on the media buzz that accompanies a primary victory (as well as a certain amount of gullibility on the part of many in the media who lack perspective). But the nation hasn't had such a wide-open presidential race in decades, and a lot of people seem confused by it all, with good reason.

Which brings me back to last Sunday's column. I asked for your suggestions for ways to conduct a more fair nomination process. I presented three current proposals: A single, nationwide primary held in every state on the same day; graduated primaries in which small states go first, grouped in random order; and rotating regional primaries, in which the nation is divided into four regions, which take turns going first.

Some of you wrote to express your overall dissatisfaction with the length of the presidential campaign or with the money needed to run for office. Those are issues that defy any meaningful solutions. We value free speech in this country, so you can't stop someone from campaigning early. And a campaign is going to need a lot of money to reach potential voters. Even if the Internet holds the promise of someday reducing those costs, spending limits are undemocratic.

Others of you supported one of the three proposals, with some variations.

Recent comments

I really don't mind the early states and I think they are helpful in...

Stewart | Jan. 13, 2008 at 9:00 p.m.

There's still 47 states waiting to elect someone plus some with...

Anonymous | Jan. 13, 2008 at 9:44 a.m.

previousnext

Latest comments

This news about the rabbit isn't new. Louree talked about this in 2003. Btw...

Max Hall issues apology

I'm embarrassed for the Utah fans if they are treating his family like...

Utes won't respond to Hall

This is all very entertaining.....and childish. Go Boise State

Emery will be key if the Cougars are to beat the aggies Wednesday.

Hall reprimanded by MWC

Actually, I love BYU football always have. Last year I had season tickets....

Utes won't respond to Hall

This whole "your fans are worse than our fans" is pointless. More than 90%...

Letters: Hall is an embarrassment

A large portion of the overall (non-Mormon and Mormon), population is sick...

Can't we remember that this was us, the fans not the teams let's not be...

BYU says Hall incident resolved

I'm sorry, but if you had any intelligence at all you would realize that Ute...

Hall reprimanded by MWC

Max's comments took away from his win, he came across sounding entitled, I'm...

Advertisements